Custom Image by Hannah Diffey
Published May 9, 2026, 9:00 AM EDT
Hannah is a senior writer and self-publisher for the anime section at ScreenRant. There, she focuses on writing news, features, and list-style articles about all things anime and manga. She works as a freelance writer in the entertainment industry, focusing on video games, anime, and literature.
Her published works can be found on ScreenRant, FinanceBuzz, She Reads, and She Writes.
Sign in to your ScreenRant account
For more than 25 years, One Piece has been defined by its anime. Toei Animation’s long-running adaptation turned Eiichiro Oda’s manga into one of the most recognizable series in entertainment, stretching past 1,100 episodes and becoming the default image of Luffy and the Straw Hats for generations of fans. For a long time, that version felt untouchable.
That changed in 2023 when Netflix’s live-action One Piece premiered and immediately changed the conversation around the franchise. Instead of feeling like a novelty, the eight-episode adaptation became a genuine creative reset that has since gotten a Season 2 and a confirmed third season. More importantly, it did something the anime rarely manages consistently anymore: it made the Straw Hats feel sharper, warmer, and more human without losing what made them iconic.
Netflix's Live-Action Quietly Fixed the Straw Hats
The biggest surprise of Netflix’s One Piece was not the production scale or the faithful set design. It was the character work. Across just eight episodes, the live-action series delivered cleaner, more emotionally direct versions of the East Blue crew than the anime often managed in dozens. It streamlined their personalities without flattening them.
Usopp may be the clearest example. In Toei’s anime, he is often remembered first for his cowardice and exaggerated comic panic, especially in earlier arcs. The live-action keeps his insecurity intact, but reframes it through vulnerability and wit. Jacob Romero’s version makes Usopp feel less like a punchline and more like an insecure storyteller trying to become brave.
Sanji received an even bigger upgrade. Taz Skylar’s portrayal keeps Sanji’s swagger, pride, and romantic charm, but strips away one of the anime’s most exhausting habits by removing the annoying pervert gag. Without that trait dominating every interaction, Sanji becomes what he was always supposed to be; a suave, fiercely loyal fighter whose charisma actually lands instead of collapsing into parody.
Even smaller character adjustments helped. Nami’s guarded cynicism feels more grounded, Zoro’s stoicism is less cartoonishly aloof, and Luffy’s optimism comes across as sincere rather than overly broad. Iñaki Godoy plays Luffy with a lighter emotional realism that makes his confidence feel contagious. The result is a Straw Hat crew that feels less exaggerated and more complete.
Why the Live-Action Now Feels Closer to Oda's Intent
Courtesy of NetflixWhat makes the live-action’s characterization so effective is that it does not feel like a rejection of Oda’s writing. It feels like a refinement of it. Oda was heavily involved in Netflix’s series, serving as executive producer and reportedly pushing rewrites, reshoots, and tonal adjustments until he was satisfied with the final result.
The Ultimate · Straw Hat Challenge Set Sail for Trivia “I’m gonna be King of the Pirates!”
⚕CrewNakama!
🌊SeasEast Blue
🍋Devil FruitsGomu Gomu!
☠VillainsFear the sea
🏆DreamsOne Piece!
SET SAIL →
01
Monkey D. Luffy accidentally ate a Devil Fruit as a child, giving him rubber-like abilities. What is the name of that fruit?
AFlame-Flame Fruit BChop-Chop Fruit CGum-Gum Fruit DSmoke-Smoke Fruit
✓ Correct! The Gum-Gum Fruit (Gomu Gomu no Mi) turned Luffy’s body into rubber. He ate it from Shanks’ treasure chest as a kid, gaining stretchy powers but losing the ability to swim forever.
✗ Overboard! The answer is the Gum-Gum Fruit. The Chop-Chop Fruit belongs to Buggy, the Flame-Flame Fruit to Ace, and the Smoke-Smoke Fruit to Captain Smoker — but Luffy’s rubber powers come from the Gomu Gomu no Mi.
NEXT →
02
Luffy’s iconic straw hat was given to him as a child by a famous pirate who inspired his dream. Who gave Luffy the hat?
AGold Roger BMonkey D. Garp CDracule Mihawk DRed-Haired Shanks
✓ Correct! Red-Haired Shanks entrusted his straw hat to young Luffy in Foosha Village, telling him to return it when he becomes a great pirate. That promise drives Luffy’s entire journey.
✗ Overboard! The answer is Red-Haired Shanks. While Gold Roger originally wore the hat, it was Shanks who passed it down to Luffy after saving his life from a Sea King — a defining moment in the series.
NEXT →
03
Before joining the Straw Hats, Sanji works as a sous chef at a floating restaurant on the ocean. What is the name of this restaurant?
AThe Galley-La BThe Baratie CThe Sea Rat DMakino’s Tavern
✓ Correct! The Baratie is the ocean-going restaurant run by Chef Zeff, Sanji’s mentor. In the live-action series, it’s one of the most stunning sets — a fully realized ship-restaurant on the open sea.
✗ Overboard! The answer is The Baratie. Run by the legendary pirate-turned-chef “Red Leg” Zeff, this floating restaurant is where Luffy recruits Sanji as the Straw Hats’ cook.
NEXT →
04
Roronoa Zoro is famous for his unique sword-fighting technique. How many swords does he wield in his signature style?
AOne BTwo CThree DFour
✓ Correct! Zoro uses Three-Sword Style (Santoryu), wielding one sword in each hand and a third in his mouth. His dream is to become the world’s greatest swordsman by defeating Dracule Mihawk.
✗ Overboard! The answer is three. Zoro’s iconic Three-Sword Style places one blade in each hand and a third clenched between his teeth — a fighting technique unique to him in the One Piece world.
NEXT →
05
Each Straw Hat crew member has a personal dream. What is Nami’s ultimate goal that drives her journey?
ATo find the One Piece treasure BTo become the greatest navigator CTo draw a complete map of the world DTo defeat every pirate on the Grand Line
✓ Correct! Nami’s dream is to draw a map of the entire world. Her cartography skills and navigation talent make her indispensable to the crew, and her passion for mapmaking was nurtured by her adoptive mother Bell-mère.
✗ Overboard! The answer is to draw a complete map of the world. Nami is a gifted cartographer whose dream goes beyond just sailing — she wants to chart every sea and island so no one is ever lost again.
NEXT →
06
A powerful Marine Vice Admiral is revealed to have a surprising family connection to Luffy. Who is this high-ranking Marine?
ACaptain Smoker BAdmiral Akainu CCaptain Morgan DVice Admiral Garp
✓ Correct! Vice Admiral Monkey D. Garp is Luffy’s grandfather. Known as “Garp the Fist,” he’s a Marine hero who wanted Luffy to become a Marine — not a pirate. Their family dynamic is a major subplot in the live-action series.
✗ Overboard! The answer is Vice Admiral Garp. Monkey D. Garp is Luffy’s grandfather and one of the most legendary Marines alive. Despite being on opposite sides of the law, their bond runs deep.
NEXT →
07
Usopp is recruited into the Straw Hat crew after the pirates help defend his home village from Captain Kuro’s Black Cat Pirates. What is the name of Usopp’s village?
AFoosha Village BShells Town CSyrup Village DCoco Village
✓ Correct! Syrup Village is Usopp’s peaceful hometown where he was known for telling tall tales. It’s also where Kaya lives, and where the crew acquires the Going Merry from her estate.
✗ Overboard! The answer is Syrup Village. Foosha Village is Luffy’s hometown, Shells Town is where Zoro was held captive, and Coco Village (Cocoyasi) is Nami’s home — but Usopp hails from Syrup Village.
NEXT →
08
The Netflix live-action adaptation was praised for its casting. Which actor plays Monkey D. Luffy?
AMackenyu BTaz Skylar CIñaki Godoy DJacob Romero Gibson
✓ Correct! Mexican actor Iñaki Godoy won fans over with his infectious energy and earnest portrayal of Luffy. Mackenyu plays Zoro, Taz Skylar is Sanji, and Jacob Romero Gibson plays Usopp.
✗ Overboard! The answer is Iñaki Godoy. The young Mexican actor perfectly captured Luffy’s boundless enthusiasm. The other actors all play Straw Hat crew members — but Luffy is all Iñaki.
REVEAL MY SCORE →
Voyage Complete Your Pirate Record
⚕
/ 8
Are you King of the Pirates — or lost at sea?
↻ SET SAIL AGAIN
That creative oversight matters because the live-action often feels like it is filtering the Straw Hats through Oda’s emotional intent rather than Toei’s decades of anime habits. The anime has long leaned on repetition, exaggeration, and recurring gags to fill time. Over more than 1,100 episodes, those traits became inseparable from the characters, even when they made them feel thinner.
The live-action does the opposite. It trims the excess and lets defining traits breathe. Sanji is flirtatious, not unbearable. Usopp is scared, not incompetent. Luffy is eccentric, not childish. That distinction may sound small, but it fundamentally changes how these characters land. Netflix’s version does not rewrite the Straw Hats. It simply presents them with more restraint and better balance.
Wit Studio Has the Chance to Follow the Better Blueprint
That is what makes Wit Studio’s upcoming One Piece remake so interesting. Announced in December 2023, The One Piece now has a confirmed release date of February 2027. The new anime is being produced by Wit Studio for Netflix and begins again from the East Blue saga. It is not just another adaptation. It is the franchise’s first real chance to rethink how these characters should function on screen.
Wit has an opportunity Toei never had, to rebuild One Piece from the start with modern pacing, animation, and stronger characterization. That means preserving Oda’s tone while avoiding the habits that slowly calcified in the original anime. If The One Piece simply recreates old performances with cleaner animation, it will miss the most important lesson Netflix already proved.
Related
One Piece's Remake Is Already A Victim Of Netflix's Biggest Problem
Netflix's One Piece remake, The One Piece, finally has a confirmed release window, but Netflix might be killing the hype before it even comes out.
The live-action established a stronger dramatic blueprint for the Straw Hats than the anime has offered in years. Wit Studio should not copy the live-action scene for scene, but it should absolutely study why those portrayals worked. If The One Piece wants to become the definitive One Piece adaptation, it should borrow the live-action’s greatest strength by treating Oda’s characters like people first, cartoons second.
First Film One Piece: The Movie
Cast Kazuya Nakai, Akemi Okamura, Kappei Yamaguchi, Hiroaki Hirata, Ikue Ôtani, Yuriko Yamaguchi
Created by Eiichiro Oda
Character(s) Monkey D. Luffy, Roronora Zoro, Nami (One Piece), Nico Robin, Usopp (One Piece), Vinsmoke Sanji, Tony Tony Chopper, Franky (One Piece), Jimbei (One Piece)
English (US) ·