A lot has been made over the years about the concept of "elevated horror," which is basically used to describe high-quality films in the genre. However, that's an unfortunate term because it dismisses the rest of the genre and it's a shame because the idea could be used for all genres, yet isn't. A great sci-fi film could be "elevated sci-fi" or a great action movie could be "elevated action," yet that qualifier isn't given to the best releases in that genre, so it shouldn't apply to horror either.
That said, there is something unique about horror in just how much fans of the genre seem to love films that are poorly received. There's a good chance that you'll find just as many fans of slashers that critics hated as you will for horror movies that ended up nominated for Academy Awards. In fact, there are plenty of horror movies that received lackluster or downright bad reviews from critics, yet are beloved by many of us.
In some cases, it's a film that was marketed incorrectly and flopped but became a cult classic. In other cases, it's a sequel that didn't live up to the original. Other times, it's a remake that's far better than it gets credit for. Yet in all these situations, we love these "bad" movies.
Bride Of Chucky (1998)
The Child's Play franchise has never really been one to receive sparkling reviews, with the original and some of the later, straight-to-DVD releases getting solid Rotten Tomatoes scores and that's it. Even though it's not among those, Bride of Chucky is actually a blast of a film.
The movie introduces the world to Tiffany Valentine, Chuck's ex-girlfriend, played by Jennifer Tilly. The character has become almost as iconic as Chucky himself and seeing the two banter together is enough to make Bride of Chucky worth a viewing. It also helps that the movie goes all in on the goofiness of the franchise.
House Of Wax (2005)
House of Wax is one of those stories that has been adapted several times on the big screen, with versions coming out in 1933 and 1953 before we got this 2005 iteration. Reviews were poor and it was up for some Golden Raspberry Awards, yet it has become a cult classic.
This version is so beloved among millennials because it's a time capsule of the 2000s, thanks to its cast featuring Jared Padalecki, Elisha Cuthbert, Paris Hilton, and Chad Michael Murray, among others. The film also features a steady hand by director Jaume Collet-Serra and some creative kills.
Halloween III: Season Of The Witch (1982)
For some people, Halloween III: Season of the Witch is looked down upon because it's an outlier in the franchise. It's the only installment to not include Michael Myers, making it feel different from every other entry.
The idea was to turn Halloween into an annual anthology release set on the night of the titular holiday, meaning this story involving witchcraft stands on its own. Despite lackluster reviews, Season of the Witch is actually a solid horror film, especially when you're not going in expecting Michael Myers.
Final Destination 3 (2006)
The Final Destination franchise is one of the most consistent in the horror genre. Every installment received relatively mixed reviews until the latest, Bloodlines, was a critical darling. Still, the entry to receive the second-worst reviews is Final Destination 3, which sits at just 44% on Rotten Tomatoes.
Final Destination 3 isn't great, yet there's a lot to like about it. The roller coaster opening is very well done, the cast features impressive talents like Mary Elizabeth Winstead, and it has some of the most creative and violent kills of the entire series, which is a major selling point.
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003)
2003's The Texas Chainsaw Massacre had an uphill battle from the start. The film is a remake of Tobe Hooper's 1974 classic and had no real chance to live up to what that delivered. While that's true, there's still plenty to appreciate here.
Marcus Nispel sets an eerie mood from the start that feels different from the original, yet remains gritty. Jessica Biel and R. Lee Ermey give solid performances, and the entire thing is brutal. Reviews were right when they said the remake was unnecessary, yet it does enough to make it a strong slasher.
I know What You Did Last Summer (1997)
The release of Scream in 1996 injected new life into the slasher genre and I Know What You Did Last Summer was an immediate reaction to that. Like Scream, the film took a bunch of popular young actors from the time period and put them in a situation where a killer hunts them down.
Reviews for the movie were poor, yet so many still love I Know What You Did Last Summer. There was even a 2025 reboot/sequel and a 2021 TV series. You come to the movie to see Jennifer Love Hewitt, Sarah Michelle Gellar, Freddie Prinze Jr., and more battle a killer, which is fun.
Saw II (2005)
The Saw franchise kind of dominated the horror landscape in the back half of the 2000s. Each year saw a new release and the box office returns were huge, yet the critical reviews kept getting worse. Even with its poor reception, Saw II is the perfect film for the franchise.
Saw II takes what worked in the first entry and expands on it, giving us more test subjects, creative traps, and way more of Tobin Bell as Jigsaw. In a lot of ways, it's the best installment of the series as it's very easy to rewatch and came before the series bogged itself down with backstory.
The Purge (2013)
The Purge is one of the most popular modern horror franchises, yet it wasn't exactly a hit with critics. No entry has more than 57% on Rotten Tomatoes, though it's the original that sits at the lowest score with 39%.
Usually, the first entry of a franchise ranks as its best but The Purge is unique in that aspect. While the sequels are mostly better and expand the world, the first works as the top horror installment. The confined location, lack of laws, and home invasion elements make for something pretty terrifying.
Freddy Vs. Jason (2003)
The entire selling point of Freddy vs. Jason was getting to see two legendary slasher villains duke it out. In that regard, Freddy vs. Jason delivered in spades because what we get from these two is really good.
It's also the rare "vs." scenario where we actually get a clear-cut winner, albeit with a tease for more in the future. Still, Freddy vs. Jason was disliked by critics, yet delivers what you want from a slasher. It's cheesy, has great kills, and never takes itself too seriously.
Jennifer's Body (2009)
When trailers came out for Jennifer's Body, it was poorly marketed to focus purely on Megan Fox's sex appeal. That made it so a lot of younger males went to see it and came away disappointed. However, the years have seen the film get re-evaluated as a feminist cult classic.
Jennifer's Body is much better than its lackluster Rotten Tomatoes score. Fox puts on her best performance alongside Amanda Seyfried, the writing is sharp, and it keeps you engaged from start to finish. There has even been talk of a sequel at some point, showing that the film has staying power.
English (US) ·