Sign in to your Collider account
Image via Paramount Pictures
In the world of filmmaking, success at the box office is never a guaranteed outcome, even when all the right elements seem to be in place. A movie can boast an intriguing premise, a talented cast, and high-quality direction, yet still fail to resonate with audiences when it hits theaters. These films often have promising prospects—whether they’re from seasoned directors or feature prominent actors—but for reasons both subtle and significant, they miss the mark commercially. Despite their potential, they become cautionary tales of how unpredictable audience tastes and market conditions can be.
The reasons behind these unexpected box office failures are often more complex than they seem. Timing can play a massive role; for instance, Mission: Impossible - Dead Reckoning Part One found itself competing with the cultural juggernauts of Barbie and Oppenheimer. Marketing may also fail to clearly communicate a film’s appeal or generate the excitement needed to draw in a wide audience. In other cases, films that seem tailor-made for success fail to click with viewers due to tonal mismatches or even just an audience not quite ready for something different. This article takes a look at some of the major movies that should have been easy home-runs but instead, they struck out.
10 'The Shawshank Redemption' (1994)
Directed by Frank Darabont
Image via Castle Rock Entertainment
Adapted from Stephen King’s novella, The Shawshank Redemption tells the story of Andy Dufresne (Tim Robbins), a banker sentenced to life in Shawshank prison for the murder of his wife and her lover—a crime he insists he didn’t commit. Over the decades, Andy forms a close bond with Ellis "Red" Redding (Morgan Freeman), a fellow inmate and the prison’s go-to man for smuggled goods. The film explores themes of hope, resilience, and redemption, set against the grim backdrop of prison. Despite its eventual status as one of the greatest films of all time, The Shawshank Redemption was a commercial disappointment upon release.
The film’s initial failure at the box office was due to its release in a competitive season, going up against hits like Pulp Fiction and Forrest Gump. Additionally, the prison drama genre lacked mainstream appeal, and the title itself didn’t convey much about the film's plot; even Robbins and Freeman blamed that. This was a surprise because when the film was tested, the scores were high, leading the studios to be optimistic about the prospects of the movie. However, The Shawshank Redemption found immense success in home video sales and frequent TV airings, becoming a timeless classic celebrated by generations. Its failure was a stepping stone to its ultimate legacy.
Your changes have been saved
The Shawshank Redemption
Director Frank Darabont
Runtime 142 minutes
9 'The Quick and the Dead' (1995)
Directed by Sam Raimi
Image via TriStar Pictures
This revisionist Western, directed by Sam Raimi, follows Ellen (Sharon Stone), a mysterious gunslinger who rides into a corrupt frontier town to compete in a high-stakes quick-draw tournament. The contest, organized by the ruthless mayor and former outlaw John Herod (Gene Hackman), pits the best sharpshooters against one another in deadly duels. Driven by her motive to avenge her father’s death at Herod’s hands, she enters the deadly tournament. The film also stars Russell Crowe and Leonardo DiCaprio, early in their Hollywood careers.
Raimi had just came off from his successful Evil Dead films and Stone was still riding the success of Basic Instinct, so the stars should have aligned for the success of the film. Despite its unique flair and star-studded lineup, The Quick and the Dead failed to connect with audiences, earning just $18 million against its $35 million budget. Its underperformance stemmed from its main genre as Westerns were largely out of fashion in the mid-1990s, which hurt its appeal. Additionally, its unique tone, which oscillated between campy action and gritty drama, also didn't help good word of mouth to spread. However, the film has since garnered a cult following and, over time, it’s come to be seen as an underrated gem within the Western genre.
Your changes have been saved
The Quick and the Dead
Runtime 107 Minutes
8 Ali (2001)
Directed by Michael Mann
Image via Sony
Michael Mann’s Ali chronicles the life and career of Muhammad Ali (Will Smith), focusing on his transformative decade from 1964 to 1974. The film follows Ali's rise to global fame, his controversial decision to refuse the Vietnam War draft, and his eventual comeback after being stripped of his title. The film highlighted iconic moments such as his legendary fights against Sonny Liston, Joe Frazier, and George Foreman, with the "Rumble in the Jungle" serving as the climax.
Despite critical acclaim for its performances and historical depth, Ali underperformed at the box office. Its lengthy runtime was one of the reasons, but it also suffered from a packed Christmas release date, which included box office smash, The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring. Additionally, the film’s introspective tone didn’t match the expectations of those anticipating a more action-packed sports drama. Though it didn’t achieve financial success, Ali has since been recognized as a solid, ambitious biopic, with many appreciating Smith’s Oscar-nominated, powerful depiction of the boxing legend.
Your changes have been saved
Director Michael Mann
Runtime 157 minutes
7 'The Island' (2005)
Directed by Michael Bay
Directed by explosion connoisseur Michael Bay, The Island is set in a dystopian future where residents of a sterile, utopian facility believe they are survivors of a contaminated Earth. They live in hopes of being selected to move to “The Island,” supposedly the last unspoiled place on the planet. However, two residents, Lincoln Six Echo (Ewan McGregor) and Jordan Two Delta (Scarlett Johansson), discover the horrifying truth that they are clones bred to provide organs for their wealthy human counterparts.
Regardless of the critical reception of his movies, Bay had never had a box office flop up until this point in his career, making the failure of The Island quite surprising. In a crowded summer calendar, the movie only opened at number four, behind Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, Wedding Crashers, and Fantastic Four. This underperformance was largely attributed to its convoluted marketing, which failed to highlight the film’s intriguing dystopian concept and instead focused on generic action tropes. The broad, generic title also did little to gauge audience interest. Over time, The Island has gained modest appreciation for its themes, making it one of the more nuanced Bay films.
Your changes have been saved
The Island
6 'Scott Pilgrim vs. the World' (2010)
Directed by Edgar Wright
Image via Universal Pictures
Directed by Edgar Wright, Scott Pilgrim vs. the World is a visually inventive film based on Bryan Lee O’Malley’s graphic novel series. The story follows Scott Pilgrim (Michael Cera) as he falls for the enigmatic Ramona Flowers (Mary Elizabeth Winstead). To date her, Scott must battle her seven evil exes in over-the-top, video game and comic book-inspired showdowns. Featuring a vibrant cast that includes Chris Evans, Brie Larson, and Kieran Culkin, the film is packed with quirky visual humor and dazzling fight scenes.
Scott Pilgrim vs. The World was first screened at the San Diego Comic Con a full month before its wide release, which met with rave reviews and reactions, giving hope for a successful box office run. However, when it was released with The Expendables and Eat Pray Love, the movie only opened in fifth place, and by the third weekend, it disappeared from the top 10. The movie faced a challenge to broaden its niche appeal and its marketing that didn’t effectively communicate its innovative style. However, the movie found a passionate cult following after its theatrical run and now it’s widely regarded as a groundbreaking film with its inventive storytelling and stylistic boldness.
Your changes have been saved
Director Edgar Wright
Runtime 113 minutes
5 'Hugo' (2011)
Directed by Martin Scorsese
Image via Paramount Pictures
Directed by Martin Scorsese, Hugo follows Hugo Cabret (Asa Butterfield), an orphaned boy living in the hidden passageways of a Paris train station. Hugo spends his days maintaining the station’s clocks and working to repair a broken automaton left behind by his late father, believing it holds a message from him. His journey leads him to Isabelle (Chloë Grace Moretz), a curious girl with a love for adventure, and her godfather, Georges Méliès (Ben Kingsley), a toymaker hiding a forgotten past as a pioneer of early cinema.
A famed director tackling a family adventure set during Christmas and using the lucrative 3D technology should have been an instant recipe for success. But at its core, Hugo is more of a heartfelt love letter to cinema than a family movie. The film’s box office struggles were attributed to its niche subject matter, which appealed more to cinephiles than general audiences. Added with strong, more straightforward family fare competition such as The Muppets and Arthur Christmas, Hugo was not able to secure the audiences it wanted. Additionally, the high production costs meant it needed a blockbuster-sized return to break even. Nevertheless, Hugo has always been recognized as a beautifully crafted and deeply personal work.
Your changes have been saved
4 'Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping' (2016)
Directed by Akiva Schaffer and Jorma Taccone
Image via Universal Pictures
Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping follows Conner4Real (Andy Samberg), a former boy band member turned solo pop sensation, as his meteoric rise begins to unravel. After his second album flops disastrously, Conner resorts to outrageous gimmicks, ill-advised collaborations, and increasingly desperate publicity stunts to maintain his relevance. The film is filled with over-the-top performances, absurd humor, and cameos from real-life music icons like Mariah Carey and Justin Timberlake.
The Lonely Island has been a constant Internet hit, with viral songs like "Jack Sparrow" and "I'm On A Boat". Andy Samberg also headlined the popular Brooklyn Nine-Nine. However, Popstar bombed at the box office, earning just $9.7 million against a $20 million budget, despite positive reviews from both critics and audiences. The film barely made a mark at the box office, debuting in eighth place. Many blamed its failure on the poor marketing, which didn’t clearly communicate its unhinged comedic tone. Additionally, being released in a busy summer made it struggle to compete with tentpole blockbusters during its release. However, the film was still able to find its audience through streaming, becoming a cult classic celebrated for its laugh-out-loud moments.
Your changes have been saved
Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping
3 'Indiana Jones & the Dial of Destiny' (2023)
Directed by James Mangold
Image via Lucasfilm
The fifth installment in the Indiana Jones franchise saw Harrison Ford reprising his iconic role as the adventurous archaeologist, but without Steven Spielberg in the director's chair. Set in 1969 during the height of the space race, Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny follows Indy as he faces a new threat: Jürgen Voller (Mads Mikkelsen), a former Nazi scientist now working with NASA, who seeks the mysterious Archimedes Dial, an artifact rumored to hold the power to manipulate time. Teaming up with his goddaughter Helena Shaw (Phoebe Waller-Bridge), Indy embarks on a globe-trotting quest to prevent the dial from going into the wrong hands.
The franchise has been a constant moneymaker, and even Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull became the highest-grossing adventure despite mixed reviews. So, studios and pundits were quite sure that this fifth entry would turn a profit. However, many pointed to a lack of the thrilling energy that defined the original trilogy, as well as a bloated runtime. Apparently, many viewers deemed the movie unnecessary after the fourth film. Signs of trouble were quite apparent after its muted Cannes premiere, and ultimately it grossed lower than Raiders of the Lost Ark at the global box office, making it an unexpected flop. The movie is still a respectable and exhilarating adventure, but a sad farewell to an iconic character.
Your changes have been saved
Runtime 2 hours and 2 minutes
2 'Mission: Impossible - Dead Reckoning Part One' (2023)
Directed by Christopher McQuarrie
Image via Paramount Pictures
Mission: Impossible – Dead Reckoning Part One follows Ethan Hunt (Tom Cruise) and his IMF team as they go up against a new, unprecedented threat: an advanced, rogue AI known as The Entity. This AI has the ability to manipulate global events and wreak havoc on the world’s power structures, and it’s in the wrong hands. Ethan and his trusty crew must stop a mysterious figure, Gabriel (Esai Morales), who seems to have personal stakes in following The Entity's orders.
This seventh installment followed Mission: Impossible - Fallout which is the franchise's best reviewed and highest-grossing movie. Moreover, the studio and analysts were hoping that the goodwill from the runaway success of Top Gun: Maverick would have a positive effect. However, timing was the movie's biggest enemy as the movie was released just a week before Barbie and Oppenheimer. The two movies created the "Barbenheimer" cultural phenomenon and effectively sucked the oxygen from other movies. The premium large format screens like IMAX were given to the Christopher Nolan movie, diminishing Dead Reckoning screens. This was unfortunate because the film was well-received by fans and critics. The sequel, Mission: Impossible - The Final Reckoning, must have a better release date in summer 2025 to avoid a similar outcome.
Your changes have been saved
Runtime 164 minutes
1 'Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga' (2024)
Directed by George Miller
Image via Warner Bros.
Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga is a prequel to Mad Max: Fury Road, exploring the backstory of Furiosa (Anya Taylor-Joy), before she became the fierce and formidable warrior in the wasteland. Set in a dystopian future, the film follows a young Furiosa as she is kidnapped by the warlord Immortan Joe’s army and taken to his stronghold of the Wasteland. As she navigates this savage world, Furiosa rises through the ranks and plans to avenge the death of her mother at the hands of Dementus (Chris Hemsworth).
Despite the anticipation surrounding a return to the Mad Max world and director George Miller’s involvement, Furiosa faced a rocky reception at the box office. Its underperformance can be attributed to one main factor: Furiosa took a different approach than its predecessor. The film is much more sprawling, character-driven and explorative, compared to the relentless, high-octane action of Fury Road. The lengthy production delays and shifts in release dates didn’t help its momentum either, as this prequel arrived seven years after the last film. Armed with glowing reviews and a strong fan following, Furiosa has the potential to find its audience on home media and streaming, paving its way to the same cult status as its predecessors. But because of this box office performance, further plans involving stories in the Wasteland were put on hold.
Your changes have been saved
Director George Miller
Runtime 148 Minutes
KEEP READING: 10 Box Office Flops Everyone Saw Coming
English (US) ·