4 hours ago
6
Most beginners think editing is where a photo gets fixed. The truth is closer to the opposite: the edit accounts for roughly 20% of the final image, and the shot you took in camera carries the other 80%.
That framing anchors a six-phase editing walkthrough from Pat Kay, who breaks down not which sliders to push but the order to think in and the reasoning behind each move. Rather than a slider-by-slider demo, Kay lays out a repeatable system built around a single question you ask before touching anything: what does the subject need? He works through a photo of a shrine set into rock, using Lightroom to take it from raw capture to finished frame. The point is a way of thinking you can carry to any image in your portfolio.
The process splits into two acts. First you restore, then you build. Restoration covers the unglamorous groundwork: lens distortion, chromatic aberration, sensor dust, crooked horizons, and distractions in the frame. Skipping this phase is the most common beginner mistake, and Kay compares it to laying the foundation of a house, since backtracking later often means redoing the entire image. The second restoration phase pulls exposure back to neutral, recovering clipped highlights and lifting crushed shadows so you're working with the most information possible before any color decisions get made.
Then the building starts, and this is where Kay says beginners blow it. He shows his own early edits as proof, saturation maxed out, contrast slammed, everything tinted purple for reasons he can no longer explain. The principle he offers instead: an edit should transport you somewhere while staying grounded in realism. Push the mood as far as it goes, but keep it believable. On an overcast day with flat light, that means resisting the urge to crank saturation the scene never had. Detail work, sharpening, texture, clarity, and grain come next, with a warning that none of it rescues a photo that wasn't working. You'll just end up with a sharper version of a picture that still doesn't land. Masking and local adjustments follow, letting you direct light, shape shadows, and select the subject so it stands out.
The advice about learning by replication is the part worth sitting with, because it runs against the standard beginner mantra. Everyone tells new photographers to find their own style. Kay argues the reverse for anyone starting out: copy someone whose work you love, rebuild their edit as closely as you can, and if possible, shoot the same location so you can match it shot for shot. This tracks with how skill develops in nearly every visual craft. Painters have copied masters for centuries, and musicians learn by playing other people's songs before writing their own. Deliberate imitation forces you to reverse-engineer decisions you'd never notice just by admiring the result. The same logic explains his caution against building presets too early. A preset locks in a look before you've explored enough to know what your look even is, which quietly caps how far you can grow. Explore widely first, learn to reproduce many aesthetics, and build your own from that foundation once you've earned it.
The final phase is the one that quietly ruins finished work: export. Crops, aspect ratios, and output sizes change depending on where the image lands, and Instagram, a print, and a portfolio each want something different. A strong edit exported wrong reads as a bad photo to whoever sees it, because the image gets judged where it lives, not inside Lightroom. Kay ties the whole sequence back to the three needs he diagnosed at the start: remove distractions, build mood, and steer the eye to the subject. Restoration answered the first, color and contrast the second, detail and masking the third. Every phase exists to serve the subject, and if the capture didn't give you a subject worth serving, no amount of editing invents one.
Watch the full breakdown in the video above to see how each phase transforms the shrine image from before to after.
English (US) ·