Netflix's 'Pirates Of The Caribbean Meets Harry Potter' Series Makes Lord Of The Rings Look Small

3 hours ago 7

Published Jul 21, 2026, 8:00 PM EDT

Tom is a Senior Staff Writer at Screen Rant, with expertise covering everything from hilarious sitcoms to jaw-dropping sci-fi epics.

Initially he was an Updates writer, though before long he found his way to the TV and movies team. He now spends his days keeping Screen Rant readers informed about the TV shows of yesteryear, whether it's recommending hidden gems that may have been missed by genre fans or deep diving into ways your favorite shows have (or haven't) stood the test of time.

Tom is based in the UK and when he's not writing about TV shows, he's watching them. He's also an avid horror fiction writer, gamer, and has a Dungeons and Dragons habit that he tries (and fails) to keep in check.

If one property holds the pop-culture crown when it comes to expansive fantasy worlds, it is The Lord of the Rings. J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle-earth has become synonymous with rich, lore-heavy fantasy settings, with every new fantastical realm created by authors, filmmakers, or TV studios inevitably compared to it. From its sprawling geography and ancient histories to its countless cultures, languages, and legends, the scale of Middle-earth is one that few, if any, fantasy series can match.

Almost no fictional universe accessible through the small screen feels as expansive as Tolkien's vast world, with one notable exception. While its tone feels like a blend of Pirates of the Caribbean and Harry Potter more than anything created by J.R.R. Tolkien, Netflix's live-action One Piece has opened the door for TV audiences to experience a world that makes Middle-earth feel astoundingly small. Its distinct locations, supernatural powers and creatures, and larger-than-life characters blend to create a fantasy setting that seems almost limitless.

Netflix's live-action One Piece adapts Eiichiro Oda's massively popular manga, following Monkey D. Luffy (Iñaki Godoy) and his crew, the Straw Hat Pirates, as they pursue the legendary One Piece treasure. For fans of prestige-quality swashbuckling action and jaw-dropping magical spectacle, it should absolutely be considered essential viewing. As an added bonus, One Piece offers the most substantial fantasy world to immerse oneself in since The Lord of the Rings was written, with a mythology that continues to expand well beyond what the Netflix series has revealed in its first 2 seasons.

Netflix’s One Piece Brings The Magic Of Harry Potter To The High Seas

Image from Netflix's One Piece Live Action Season 2 shows Brook with his afro and top hat playing violin while standing on his boat with the whale laboon smiling in front of him.

As a viewing experience, Netflix's live-action One Piece is a riveting blend of Pirates of the Caribbean and Harry Potter, combining the former's high-seas adventure with the latter's uniquely charming whimsical sense of fantasy. The plot of One Piece revolves around the relentlessly optimistic young pirate Monkey D. Luffy, who dreams of one day becoming the King of the Pirates. This quest leads him across seas filled with eccentric islands and bizarre creatures, which he survives thanks in no small part to his unnaturally stretchy limbs.

The Pirates of the Caribbean comparison is particularly easy to understand. One Piece embraces the tried-and-tested tropes of great pirate stories, from treasure hunts and naval battles to colorful crews and larger-than-life villains. The more fantastical Pirates of the Caribbean characters like Davey Jones would be right at home in One Piece’s world, and the same applies to plenty of One Piece’s pirates. Plus, like the Pirates movies, the live-action One Piece is full of swashbuckling action from start to finish.

However, One Piece also tonally shares the charming magic of Harry Potter. The Wizarding World works because its supernatural elements are woven into everyday life, making the extraordinary feel strangely familiar. One Piece takes a similar approach through Devil Fruits, one of which gave Luffy his own powers, and its various fantastical elements. The result is a world where an apparently ordinary island can contain something completely unexpected, with plenty of moments in the live-action One Piece that are as visually delightful as the Wizarding World of the Harry Potter movies.

That combination means that Netflix's live-action One Piece is guaranteed to appeal to fans of either franchise. Those who enjoy the Pirates of the Caribbean movies will find plenty of energetic sword fights, naval battles, and sea monsters to enjoy. Meanwhile, Harry Potter fans will be right at home with the cozy and colorful portrayal of the series most fantastical elements. To add to the appeal, all of this takes place in a world that’s quietly become perhaps the biggest in modern fantasy fiction, even compared to Middle-earth.

The World Of One Piece Dwarfs Middle-earth

Netflix One Piece live-action Luffy and Nami on their ship smiling and happy

As expansive as Tolkien's Middle-earth is, the source material for Netflix's live-action One Piece makes its setting feel almost claustrophobic by comparison. Tolkien created an extraordinary mythology across The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings, The Silmarillion, and numerous other writings, but Eiichiro Oda's One Piece manga has now reached around 1,175 chapters and is still ongoing. Fans of Tolkien shouldn’t let One Piece’s comparative modernity fool them: to say that the lore behind the Netflix show is extensive is an understatement.

It’s impossible to argue that One Piece is or will ever be as influential as The Lord of the Rings. Tolkien’s work fundamentally shaped modern fantasy and remains one of the most important works of fiction ever published. However, the fantasy world Eiichiro Oda has created is, by this point, simply much bigger and deeper than Middle-earth in several measurable ways. Tolkien's world has an extraordinary amount of lore, but Oda has spent decades continuously adding to his own setting, often turning seemingly minor details into major parts of its mythology.

This is immediately apparent in the sheer scale of the One Piece map. The story has moved across enormous stretches of ocean and introduced countless locations, each with its own culture and history. The world's charted history also stretches back around five millennia, with more abstract pre-history mentioned too, putting it within a few thousand years of the deep historical timelines associated with Middle-earth. Hundreds of named characters and locations further contribute to a setting that feels increasingly impossible to fully map.

Middle-earth may remain pop culture's benchmark for an expansive fantasy world, but One Piece quietly beats it at its own game. The difference is that Oda's world-building is still happening in real time, with new information continually reshaping what audiences understand about the world. What’s more, Netflix has only explored a tiny portion of that mythology so far. If the live-action One Piece series continues long enough, viewers could eventually experience a fantasy universe whose scope is not merely comparable to Middle-earth, but greater than it.