Marvel Has Only One Path to Fix Its Most Controversial Spider-Man Story

1 week ago 9
spider-man one more day peter mj mayday spider-girl mephisto (3)

Published Mar 4, 2026, 5:38 PM EST

Jared is a writer, editor, and Communications Studies graduate who loves popular nerd culture (almost anything to do with Marvel, DC, Star Wars, or The Lord of the Rings) and the interactive storytelling medium. Jared's first console was the PS1, wherein he fell for Spider-Man, Spyro the Dragon, and Crash Bandicoot.

Sign in to your ScreenRant account

Earth-616 and The Amazing Spider-Man are forever tainted by how egregious the “One More Day” storyline is. Today, a lot of readers have lost faith in Spider-Man’s ongoing series, despite some runs since being interesting and meaningful, as the status quo it delivered has been prevalent for the last 18 years.

Spider-Man (or His Kid) Must Beat the Devil, Literally

Nick Spencer’s Amazing Spider-Man runThe Amazing Spider-Man #74 (2018), specifically—explicitly prophesies that Mephisto’s defeat would come via Peter and MJ’s daughter, Mayday, who becomes Spider-Girl. This remains one of the more fascinating story beats to be proposed in this era, particularly as it teases a war waged by Mephisto that is won only by somehow having Mayday there.

Of course, a lot would need to transpire in the present era for this to be remotely possible, such as Peter and MJ’s daughter reaching them via some sort of multiverse shenanigans, and no future solicitations seem to suggest that anything like it will occur by The Amazing Spider-Man #1000. If Marvel ever wants to renew The Amazing Spider-Man and debut an agreeable status quo, though, this would be how it achieves that.

One More Day Has Irreparably Ruined Spider-Man

spider-man peter mj one more day

Sadly, even if Marvel did fulfill Mephisto’s feared prophecy, it’d probably be met with more disdain. Retconning this event so soon after it had struck would’ve been a quick balm for readers, and it’s fascinating that it hasn’t been resolved or reversed in almost two decades, for instance, but surely Marvel could’ve corrected it sooner, and preferably once The Amazing Spider-Man’s readership became vocally furious.

Now, no editorial or creative team should ever be beholden to the opinions and plights that readers have at the cost of the status quo or storytelling potential. That said, it’s plain to see how poor The Amazing Spider-Man’s prestige as an ongoing comic book series has been since “One More Day” and “Brand New Day.”

Spider-Man Swinging in Dodson Comic Art

First Appearance Amazing Fantasy

Alias Peter Parker, Ben Reilly, Otto Octavius, Yu Komori, Kaine Parker, Pavitr Prabhakar, William Braddock, Miles Morales, Kurt Wagner

Alliance Avengers, Fantastic Four, X-Men, Secret Defenders, Future Foundation, Heroes for Hire, Mighty Avengers, New Avengers, Web-Warriors

Race Human

Read Entire Article