Dutton Ranch Review: Paramount+'s New Western Takes All The Best Parts Of Yellowstone & Makes Them Better

Taylor Sheridan revives the Yellowstone franchise with Dutton Ranch — Beth and Rip's new series that makes a case for why it might even be better than the original. Much has been said about how Sheridan created an expansive TV franchise with core Western sensibilities. Standalone shows like Mayor of Kingstown, Tulsa King, Landman, and, more recently, The Madison all have their respective fan bases, but nothing has come close to the success of the original Yellowstone show. For the longest time, the franchise only expanded back in time with prequels, but 2026 changes that with sequels.

Luke Grimes' Marshals opened this new era of Yellowstone on CBS back in March. That said, shifting to be more of a law enforcement procedural set in the Yellowstone universe doesn't exactly scratch the itch left by the original's ending. This is where Dutton Ranch comes in — Paramount+'s newest installment in the Sheridan-created world. Spearheaded by Kelly Reilly and Cole Hauser as Beth and Rip, Dutton Ranch follows the pair in their new life after John III's death, and Yellowstone was sold back to Broken Rock. For context, the flagship ended with the pair moving to Dillon, Montana, in a smaller but more remote ranch that's their own. However, early events of Dutton Ranch motivate them to move out of the state and down south to Texas.

Dutton Ranch Is Yellowstone Season 6 — Only Better

Arguably, Beth and Rip are John III's true heirs. The pair was the most loyal allies to Kevin Costner's Dutton family patriarch — so much so that even when they disagreed with his decisions, they found a way to still honor him time and again. Beyond that, Beth and Rip, both as individuals and a couple, are arguably the most interesting from the original Yellowstone ensemble, making it fairly easy to endear Dutton Ranch to anyone who loved the flagship — at least in the first four of its nine-episode debut season.

Impressively, Dutton Ranch takes the show and the pair to an entirely different direction by putting them in arguably their most difficult situation yet. Tragedy over tragedy, it's difficult not to feel bad and start rooting for them, a good way to sell the show, especially for those who weren't fans of the Dutton way in Montana. Yellowstone's main family wasn't particularly known for being righteous — at best, they are morally gray. Dutton Ranch acknowledges that. In fact, it doesn't try to run away from the Dutton legacy, and in return, Beth and Rip aren't haunted by it, unlike Kayce in Marshals.

In Texas, Beth and Rip aren't the bigwigs that they were in Montana. Granted that John III and his family spent the majority of Yellowstone dealing with a crisis or two, the challenges that the pair faces in Rio Palma are more urgent and grounded. At the core of Beth and Rip's goal is to preserve their land, but most importantly, their right to a good life. There's no legacy to protect or patriarch to please; they just want to live quietly with Carter. This change of pace is reflected in Beth's softer characterization in Dutton Ranch, although it doesn't mean that she no longer has her signature killer instinct. Everything that made her so exciting to watch in Yellowstone carries over in the series, but this time, the new neo-Western takes the time to also highlight other aspects of her character.

Rip remains loyal and fair. He stays true to his promise to John III to take care of Beth in the Yellowstone finale, which is a great sign for anyone who's worried that their dynamic might change to create new conflict in Dutton Ranch. Admittedly, however, the series is slow to move his character forward. While Beth and even Rip make themselves known in Rio Palma, Rip mostly deals with the ranch. The good thing is that the remaining episodes of Dutton Ranch season 1 are set up to show more of him, as he takes charge in steering their ranch in the right direction.

Dutton Ranch Is Exactly What The Yellowstone Franchise Needs After Kevin Costner's Era

It would be a major disservice to Dutton Ranch not to discuss its new characters. While Beth and Rip are at the center of its storytelling, it is able to create a new world that is inhabited by equally interesting people, and that's integral to its future as it moves out of Costner's shadow. The Johnsons are reminiscent of the Duttons of Montana, but there's enough distinction between them to offer viewers something new.

Annette Bening as Beluah Jackson is a force to be reckoned with; her interactions with Beth have been electric. Drawing parallels with Costner's role, Dutton Ranch's new matriarch is arguably more dynamic than John III. In its first four episodes, the show has already shown multiple sides of her that could make her into a more interesting character as it goes on. Ed Harris is also great as Rio Palma's veterinarian with an interesting past. His relationship with Beth is immediately refreshing — almost nothing like she's had in the franchise. It's definitely curious where Dutton Ranch is going with their dynamic moving forward.

Dutton Ranch's legacy actors are great, unsurprisingly, but the neo-Western also does a great job of rounding out the ensemble with supporting cast members. Each new character introduced in the spinoff has been properly introduced with the intention that everyone has a compelling story on their own, including Rip's new ranch helpers, J. R. Villarreal's Azul and Marc Menchaca's Zachariah. Juan Pablo Raba's Joaquin has shades of Yellowstone's Jamie in him, so it's interesting what kind of future he will have in Dutton Ranch. Meanwhile, Jai Courtney's Rob-Will is as despicable as a bad guy can get, which offers an avenue to go against the stereotype, especially with the kind of introduction he has in the series.

Finally, it's a welcome development to see Finn Little's Carter getting his own story separate from Beth and Rip, effectively representing the new generation of Duttons despite him not being blood-related to the infamous family. It's difficult not to draw some comparisons between what Dutton Ranch is doing with him and Marshals with Tate, who hasn't really had any compelling personal narrative in the CBS procedural.

Ultimately, Dutton Ranch is perfect for anyone who loves and misses Yellowstone, but its appeal goes beyond that. It is stripped of the more frivolous and soap opera-like storytelling tendencies of the flagship. At its core is a family fighting for a future. While Beth and Rip's love story is the show's backbone, it's rich with new narrative opportunities that could make the franchise more expansive.