10 “Love Island” Gift Ideas That Are the Next Best Thing to Joining the Islanders

TinyTrueNorth Baby Bodysuit ($11+)

For fellow new parents who still watch "Love Island USA' religiously, it doesn't get much better than this onesie — and unsurprisingly, it has rave reviews. "The onesie is sooo soft and adorable!" writes one of many Etsy shoppers who have given it a five-star rating. "The quality is amazing. I gave it to my pregnant sister, who is obsessed with 'Love Island,' and she loved it so much."

Lush Sticky Dates Shower Gel ($13)

Season 6 contestant Leah Kateb's shower routine practically broke the internet after her time on the show. One of her first viral TikToks filmed after the villa, featured Lush Sticky Dates shower gel, which immediately became the body wash to own and sold out both in-stores and online.

But her routine didn't stop there. Kateb also uses L'Occitane Shea Body Shower Oil ($12), followed by either the EOS 24H Moisture Body Lotion in Vanilla Cashmere ($12) or Kiehl's Crème de Corps Body Butter ($49), depending on her mood. Each one makes a great gift on its own (or an even better one when bundled together).

One of our former editors put the entire routine to the test and loved it. Learn more in our review of Leah Kateb's shower routine.

Editor Quote: "After the entire routine, my skin was left feeling soft and (in Kateb's words) 'ma ma ma ma moisturized' with a beautiful glow that glistened in the sun. The vanilla cashmere scent lasted all night long, and I even woke up the next morning with the fragrance still lingering on my skin." — Anvita Reddy, former assistant shopping editor

Maybelline Lifter Liner and Lifter Gloss Lip Holiday Gift Set ($20)

Maybelline is famously the makeup partner behind the fully stocked "Love Island USA" glam room — a fact viewers clock immediately. But I, and former contestants, can confirm the partnership is the real deal: these products are genuinely working overtime in the villa. Case in point: this giftable lip duo. It comes with a creamy liner and the show's most-talked-about hero: the Lifter Gloss. It hydrates, adds shine, and makes lips look plumper without the telltale stickiness so many glosses have. Instead, it's downright buttery.

Newmowa Selfie Light ($22, originally $26)

Maybe you know and love a "Love Island" fan who makes TikToks about the show — or maybe they're just as active on social media as the contestants themselves. Either way, this is the selfie light Alix Earle recommended that's since gone viral for instantly leveling up photos and videos so anyone can look their absolute best. Our editors put it to the test to show the before-and-after results, and they're worth a look. Check them out in our "Alix Earle Selfie Light" review.

Editor Quote: "In short, the Newmowa selfie light is incredible. But I didn't believe the hype until I had it in my hands and started using it myself. The many, many TikToks I scrolled through made the quality look promising, but I almost felt like the illumination would be too bright and harsh for me. When I looked at these comparison shots side-by-side, I was blown away." — Sarah Wasilak, shopping director

Custom Neon Sign ($22)

The "Love Island USA" villa — and every spin-off property — is famous for its kitschy-cute neon signs, from the iconic "This Must Be the Place" to the beloved "Soul Ties." Which brings me to a gift idea I'm genuinely obsessed with: a custom neon sign made just for the Love Island fan in your life. Pick a phrase that's meaningful to them (or villa-coded), and you've got a present that feels both personal and on-theme.

Official "Love Island USA" Water Bottle ($32)

As promised, I couldn't resist including the water bottle contestants always have on hand to stay hydrated in the Fiji sun. It's double-walled and made of stainless steel to keep cold drinks cold and hot drinks hot — but most importantly, it looks just like the ones on the show, complete with your gift recipient's name on the side.

Official Love Island White & Pink Medium Personalized Suitcase ($101)

Just like it feels obligatory to include "Love Island's" signature personalized water bottles, the same goes for the suitcases Islanders roll in with on day one — and wheel out with when it's sadly time to depart. Personalize it with the "Love Island" fan's name, and we can practically guarantee they'll gasp when they open it.

iHome Hollywood Vanity Mirror PRO with Built in Bluetooth ($140, originally $250)

If the "Love Island" fan in your life doesn't already have a full getting-ready setup, this mirror will make them feel like they're in the show's Glam Room. It has three color modes, four dimmable brightness levels, a 10x magnification mirror, and a Bluetooth speaker to take calls or listen to music while they do their makeup.

Barefoot Dreams CozyChic Throw ($147, originally $158)

It's no secret that keeping up with "Love Island" is basically a full-time job, which is why your favorite binge-watcher needs the essentials to stay cozy for the hours (and hours) of viewing ahead. As far as I'm concerned, this is the coziest blanket on the market — approved by multiple Popsugar editors and plenty of celebrities we've interviewed for our My Must Haves franchise, including Khloé Kardashian and Olivia Culpo. Check out our Barefoot Dreams CozyChic Throw review for all the details.

Editor Quote: "I expected it to be soft and warm since the brand is practically synonymous with all things cozy — the product name is 'CozyChic' after all. That said, reading about how good it feels really doesn't do it justice. Like silk pajamas or a cashmere sweater, it's hard to justify the cost until you feel it against your skin. As soon as I took it out of the packaging, my 4- and 7-year-old boys dove for the couch to curl up with it and didn't want to get up. At 54 by 72 inches, it's also large enough for two people to comfortably share — no tug of war necessary." — Angela Elias, contributing shopping editor

Marisa Petrarca (she/her) is a contributing editor for PS Shopping and has over seven years of experience writing and editing beauty, fashion, and lifestyle content. She was previously the senior beauty editor at Grazia USA and the style and beauty editor at Us Weekly. Now freelancing, her work has been featured in Cosmopolitan, Allure, Marie Claire, and more.