Why You Need a Tri-Reflector for Portraits

6 hours ago 11

A small silver umbrella throws hard, sparkly light that flatters a fashion model and can carve every line into an older face. If you shoot business portraits, you make the call between that punch and the forgiveness of a large soft source on almost every job.

Karl Taylor of Visual Education puts that choice to a direct test, lighting a 63-year-old man with a single 80 cm textured silver umbrella after earlier rounds with softboxes, including a 150 cm octabox in a clamshell arrangement. Taylor is upfront that this is beauty lighting, closer in character to a beauty dish than to anything he'd normally pick for an older executive. His preferred alternative is a 150 cm or 170 cm white umbrella with a solid white interior. He steers away from shoot-through white umbrellas, since they spray light all over a location. That large solid white umbrella gets you close to the look of the 150 cm octabox in a package that's far easier to carry, which is a useful substitution if you work in offices and conference rooms where setup space and load-in time are tight.

Placement is where the setup starts to take shape. The umbrella sits slightly off axis so Taylor can shoot past it, and a tri-reflector goes in below the face. He's blunt that the shot won't work without that reflector. To position it, he stands on the subject's mark, opens the three panels, and tilts them until he can see the umbrella's reflection filling every panel from the subject's point of view. The first frame at a power setting of 5 comes in a little under, so he adds half a stop and immediately flags how textural the light looks on skin.

With only one light, the background settles into a plain mid-gray. Taylor brings a background light back in for a glow behind the subject, finds it far too bright, takes a stop and a half off, and moves it closer to the wall while turning it slightly toward the sitter. He composes this frame in the opposite direction from his earlier portraits, leaving space on the left side. Once the glow looks right, he nudges the key up by a tenth or two to freshen the face. The result is noticeably more contoured than anything he got from the softboxes, with more bite and sparkle in the skin and eyes, though he points out that a subject with deeper wrinkles or a different facial structure might not carry it as well.

Then he pulls the tri-reflector out entirely, predicting it will add about 10 years to his subject. That reflector has been supplying a large share of the exposure, so he expects a sharp drop in brightness along with heavier shadows under the eyes and across the face. The white studio floor is quietly helping by bouncing some light back up, and Taylor notes that a dark office with dark carpet would make the result even harsher. He raises the exposure slightly to recover some of the loss and shoots again.

The result is not as bad as he expected. With the exposure lifted slightly, the light and shape hold up, just with more punch, and he thinks a man's facial character can usually carry it. He wouldn't recommend the setup for an older woman's portrait at all, and certainly not without the tri-reflector, since the fill bouncing up under the face and eyes is what makes the difference.

The video closes on a side-by-side of the frames with and without the reflector, which shows exactly how much fill it was adding.

Read Entire Article