High ISO has a reputation as the setting that wrecks an image, so plenty of people underexpose or drag their shutter just to keep the number down. That habit costs sharp frames in dim light, and it rests on a misunderstanding of where noise actually comes from.
An accidental frame of him walking on a beach in the Marquesas, taken by his friend Jeremy at ISO 16,000 in full daylight, is what sent Pierre T. Lambert digging into the topic, and to him, it looked more like film than a mistake. Lambert walks through the physics in plain terms. The light reaching your sensor depends on three things: the scene, the aperture, and the shutter speed. ISO adds no light at all and only amplifies the signal the sensor already collected, much like turning up a quiet recording until you hear a hiss that was there all along. Working with a Sony a7 V, he now shoots regularly at settings he used to avoid.
The grain itself comes from light arriving as particles. Lambert compares it to rain on pavement: in a downpour, every patch gets soaked evenly, but at the start of a shower, one spot catches three drops while the one next to it catches none. Low light works the same way, with neighboring pixels collecting noticeably different amounts, and that unevenness is the noise you see. His side-by-side test makes the case hard to argue with. Under identical light, shutter speed, and aperture, he shot one frame at ISO 500 and brightened it five stops in post, then shot another at ISO 16,000 and left it untouched. Zoomed in, the pushed ISO 500 file is actually worse, a difference he calls subtle but very surprising. Underexposing to protect a low ISO and rescuing it later in Lightroom leaves you with a noisier file, because the light you never captured is gone.
That also explains the beach frame. He had just been photographing horseback riding on that beach, and his shutter speed was still at 1/2,000 s. For someone walking, 1/500 s or even 1/250 s would have been plenty, so he let in only a quarter of the light he needed. He was shooting in manual with auto ISO, and the camera did exactly its job, turning the gain all the way up to ISO 16,000. The setting behind the mistake was his shutter speed, not his ISO.
Lambert also separates the two kinds of noise you'll run into. Luminance noise is fine and even, and it can pass for film. Color noise shows up as multicolored blotches, the ugly kind, though it's also the simplest to clean up, and most editing software already suppresses a good deal of it by default. In his experience, older cameras produced far worse color noise than current ones. He's comfortable working in the tens of thousands and occasionally goes as high as 51,200. He also points out that most of the noise people fret over goes unnoticed, especially on a phone screen, and he has seen big brands buy photos with plenty of noise and blow them up on 10-meter displays without complaint.
His approach to choosing ISO is to set it last. Shutter speed comes first, chosen for the motion in the scene, then aperture for depth of field, and ISO lands wherever the exposure needs it. For a shot of hikers wearing headlamps, he needed at least 1/50 s to keep them sharp, which pushed his camera to ISO 25,600. A noisy photo can be cleaned up, and a blurry one can't. High ISO still carries real costs, and he shows them directly: an image shot two stops dark at a high ISO and corrected later falls apart badly, while a correctly exposed frame at the same setting holds up.
Highlights are the other cost. Raise ISO without changing anything else and the image keeps brightening until the highlights turn pure white, and no slider brings them back. In two frames at ISO 12,800, the correctly exposed one keeps its detail in the whites while the other is clipped, so overexposure is what kills highlights, and at a correct exposure, the noise shows up first in the shadows. He also covers the extended settings on Sony bodies, marked with two bars under the ISO value, which are computed rather than native. Side by side, ISO 50 clips highlights about a stop sooner than ISO 100, so an ND filter is the better tool when you want a slower shutter in bright light.
Sometimes a lower ISO really is the better choice. His handheld Milky Way shot at ISO 25,600 and 1 s would have come out much cleaner at ISO 1,600 and 15 seconds, but documenting the scene mattered more to him than a clean file. The point is to know what a trade-off costs when you make it.
His recommendation is to leave ISO on auto with an upper limit, 51,200 on his a7 V, and keep your attention on shutter speed for sharpness or blur and aperture for depth of field. In manual with auto ISO, he rechecks the shutter speed every time the scene changes. Aperture priority with a minimum shutter speed takes even that step off your plate.
Finding your own ceiling is the homework: shoot one scene at every ISO, doubling from 100, stop where the noise bothers you, then set your limit a notch or two higher, since the denoised and untouched versions of one frame in the video show how much noise you can recover in post.

7 hours ago
2







English (US) ·