Toorak townhouse war takes a new turn as Real Housewives star launches fresh legal action to stop her wealthy socialite sister evicting her teenage daughter from multimillion-dollar property

1 week ago 36

Real Housewives of Melbourne star Venus Behbahani has launched fresh legal action against her socialite sister Rebekah and her rich lister brother-in-law-to-be Alex Waislitz over a ritzy $2 million Toorak property.

The wealthy sisters have been battling for ownership of the home for three years after Venus took Rebekah and her fiancé Alex to court in 2023 claiming they had reneged on a promise to gift the house to her. 

However, the Supreme Court dismissed the lawsuit in September, finding that while an agreement had been made between the sisters, Venus technically had no claim to the ritzy mansion, which is owned by Alex's investment company, Thorney Equities. 

Justice Claire Harris subsequently ordered that Venus's teenage daughter had to vacate the property by October 16, but the former reality TV star is now filing for a stay on the order ahead of her appeal. 

Venus has two children – Giselle, 17, and Sophia, 12 – from a previous relationship and shares her youngest – Izak, six, and Cherry Blossom, three – with her husband Lord James Clark. 

Daily Mail understands that Giselle is the child currently living in the Toorak property, after she decided she did not wish to move to the UK with her mother and stepfather. 

Real Housewives of Melbourne star Venus Behbahani (left) has launched fresh legal action against her socialite sister Rebekah (right) and her richlister brother-in-law-to-be Alex Waislitz over a ritzy $2million Toorak property

When Daily Mail approached Venus for comment, she responded: 'The Court has directed that certain matters remain confidential, and I respect its decision in that regard. 

'I do not wish to comment further on the proceedings at this stage. 

'My priority is my family's wellbeing, and I kindly ask that our privacy, particularly my children's personal circumstances, be respected.' 

Venus, who currently lives in London with her partner James, appeared before the court via video link last Thursday, filing an application for stay ahead of her appeal in a bid to prevent her sister from evicting her daughter. 

The mother-of-four, who is a qualified lawyer, will now be representing herself in court after she revealed to the court that she did not meet the cost requirements for her lawyers from Birchgrove Legal. 

'The ultimatum was put to me that unless I met the cost requirements, they would cease to act,' she told the court, according to Herald Sun.

'Because they were [the solicitors] on record, I couldn't file my leave to appeal.'

Reports first emerged in early 2023 that Venus had launched court action against her sister over a deal between them involving the luxury house, which is situated in one of Australia's wealthiest suburbs. 

According to documents filed in the Victorian Supreme Court at the time, Venus claimed she was given the ritzy Toorak townhouse during the short time her sister Rebekah separated from her billionaire fiancé Alex.

The wealthy sisters have been battling for ownership of the home for three years after Venus took Rebekah and her fiancé Alex (right) to court in 2023 claiming they had reneged on a promise to gift the house to her

The former reality star – who starred on Real Housewives from 2016 to 2018 – moved into the home in December 2019 with her oil entrepreneur husband James and their children.

Alex's company, Thorney Equities, lodged a counterclaim, seeking to evict the family from the house.

At the time, Rebekah claimed she was very distressed when her sister, 'who was not financially secure', showed her a document in 2019 and said 'she needed to sign it'.

Thorney Equities' case was based on the situation in which she signed the document, called a 'deed of gift', giving the home to her sister.

Rebekah said 'by reason of her distressed state' she didn't understand what the document meant.

She further claimed Venus was 'in a highly… angry state' when she took her sister's hand and had her sign the document using a thumb print with ink on it, accusing Venus of become physically violent.

However, the judge later found there was no evidence that Venus was 'angry or aggressive or forcing Rebekah to act in a particular way'. 

'I reject Rebekah's evidence that Venus pulled her hair when they were downstairs and that their interaction was "becoming physical",' Justice Harris said, according to court documents seen by Daily Mail. 

'No other evidence supports that assertion. 

However, the Supreme Court dismissed the lawsuit in September, finding that while an agreement had been made between the sisters, Venus technically had no claim to the ritzy mansion, which is owned by Alex's investment company, Thorney Equities

'I also find that it is implausible that Venus engaged in any such aggressive physical behaviour at that time because all of the evidence... was to the effect that a short time later they had a family Shabbat dinner at which Rebekah and Venus were present and behaved in a way to indicate that they were happy.' 

Justice Harris went on to say Rebekah had changed her account of what happened regarding the document she signed, saying she recalled preparing the 'deed of gift' in December 2019, but later changed the date to August 2020. 

'She first pleaded that she had been forced to sign it at a time in December 2019 in a state of extreme distress before her baby was born, and because of her separation from Alex,' Justice Harris said. 

'Following the second amendment to the defence she pleaded that she signed the document in August 2020, well after her daughter had been born, and when she was separated from Alex. 

'Rebekah's explanation that she simply "mixed up her dates" is implausible. 

'She had originally identified the date on which she said she was asked to sign an earlier document by reference to very memorable circumstances, being distress relating to her unborn baby, and being separated from Alex. 

'She later changed the date on which she alleged the document was signed to a time when both of those circumstances were long past.' 

Nevertheless, the judge found in September this year that the 'deed of gift' did not hold up legally, meaning Venus had no right to ownership of the townhouse. 

The matter will be heard before the Supreme Court again on November 20 during a costs hearing, while Venus's stay application will be addressed by Justice Harris on December 7. 

Read Entire Article