'The continued flood of AI reports has basically made the security list almost entirely unmanageable': Linus Torvalds laments how people are wasting the Linux team's time with LLMs

3 weeks ago 15
A rendered image showing an AI speech bubble icon over blurred programming code background, symbolizing chatbot communication, machine learning, cloud data exchange and futuristic digital interaction (Image credit: Witthaya Prasongsin via Getty Images)

In the world of software, it's common knowledge that Linus Torvalds isn't one to mince his words, and in a post about the latest kernel release candidate on the Linux mailing list archive, he was critical about people using AI tools to find bugs or other issues. Not because they used AI in the first place, but because countless people are essentially submitting messages that basically just say, 'here's a bug.'

The missive in question (via The Register) starts with a note about how new drivers make up roughly half of the kernel update, especially GPU ones, with the rest of the changes covering "networking, core kernel, filesystems, and arch updates."

Linux's creator explains that the use of AI tools isn't the issue: it's just that it is something that numerous other people are also doing, and the constant influx of messages that are effectively nothing more than 'I used AI and it found this bug' is just wasting everyone's time and effort to process.

Torvalds has no problem with the use of AI in software development, and for many engineers and full-time coders, LLMs are a great way of offloading some of the drudgery of the job or for testing out ideas before committing to a task. The problem here is that almost anyone can use a large language model to scan through millions of lines of code and find an issue or two somewhere.

"If you found a bug using AI tools, the chances are somebody else found it too," Torvalds notes. "If you actually want to add value, read the documentation, create a patch too, and add some real value on *top* of what the AI did."

It wouldn't surprise me if the Linux team ultimately end up creating a tool that automatically filters all such submissions, rejecting those that don't offer code solutions to the problems that AI has found.

Keep up to date with the most important stories and the best deals, as picked by the PC Gamer team.

And if that tool just so happens to be an AI-based one, then so much the better.

Secretlab Titan Evo gaming chair in Royal colouring, on a white background

Nick, gaming, and computers all first met in the early 1980s. After leaving university, he became a physics and IT teacher and started writing about tech in the late 1990s. That resulted in him working with MadOnion to write the help files for 3DMark and PCMark. After a short stint working at Beyond3D.com, Nick joined Futuremark (MadOnion rebranded) full-time, as editor-in-chief for its PC gaming section, YouGamers. After the site shutdown, he became an engineering and computing lecturer for many years, but missed the writing bug. Cue four years at TechSpot.com covering everything and anything to do with tech and PCs. He freely admits to being far too obsessed with GPUs and open-world grindy RPGs, but who isn't these days?

Read Entire Article