The Best Valentine’s Day Gifts, From "Heated Rivalry" Finds to Hailey Bieber Lingerie

Vineyard Vines Super-Soft Knit Pajama Set ($50, originally $150)

When it comes to gifting, it's easy to assume that bigger budgets mean better gifts. But between you and me, a great deal never hurts. This pajama set is just as comfortable, stretchy, and buttery-soft as some of the most sought-after sleepwear brands — and it's currently 80 percent off. Plus, it's Vineyard Vines, so no one would ever guess it comes in under $75. It's the kind of gift she'll reach for again and again.

Victoria's Secret Wicked Hearts and Roses Embroidery Unlined Balconette Bra ($75)

Chances are your partner highly respects Hailey Bieber's fashion choices, so why not get her this luxe Valentine's Day embroidered heart lingerie bra? Bieber looks stunning in it, and your partner will, too. It's a sultry little gesture you both can enjoy. And if you really want to top it off, you can get the matching Victoria's Secret Hearts and Broses Embroidery Thong Panty ($30).

Editor Quote: "The thing about this set that I'm not sure if a picture can capture is just how beautiful it is. The stitching is well thought-out and the embroidery is gorgeous. I feel like a princess every time I put it on and it instantly gives me a boost of confidence." — Haley Lyndes, shopping staff writer

Sene Studio Cumulus 90's Baby Tee ($78)

Peloton instructor Emma Lovewell teamed up with Sene Studio on a collection of optimal '90s basics, and there will never be a time when she doesn't thank you for gifting her a fresh, white vintage tee like this one. It comes in the perfect pre-shrunken crop, and it's luxuriously soft. She'll grab it to wear with everything from jeans to sweats.

Slip x Skims Contour Sleep Mask ($96)

This isn't your average sleep mask — celebrities like Ashley Tisdale, Rita Ora, and Shea McGee can't get enough of its soft, luxe feel and clever design, complete with eye indents that won't mess up lashes or cause any discomfort. And for Valentine's Day, Slip teamed up with Skims on this limited edition, iconic style that's as cute as it is comfy. Read our Slip Sleep Mask review for more.

Editor Quote: "The silky fabric feels soft to the touch and it is thick enough to stop any light from piercing through." — Shelcy Joeseph, former contributing editor

Uniqlo Airism Boxer Briefs ($15)

These aren't just any run-of-the-mill boxer briefs, they're the same Airism briefs Shane Hollander (Hudson Williams) and Ilya Rozanov (Connor Storrie) wear in "Heated Rivalry." We confirmed with the Uniqlo team that costume designer Hanna Puley did, in fact, use the brand's underwear on the show — and honestly, we think it would make the perfect Valentine's Day gift for the man in your life.

L.L. Bean Scotch Plaid Flannel Sleep Pants ($60)

These cozy Scotch Plaid Flannel Sleep Pants are basically a hug in pant form. Soft, warm, and comfy enough for lounging, napping, or Netflix binges; they're the kind of gift he'll actually wear (and love) this Valentine's Day.

Hey Dude Paul Shoe ($80)

We know the jury's still out on whether Hey Dude shoes are stylish, but I personally think guys can rock them. The men in my life love how comfy and easy they are to slip on, and this pair is extra fashionable thanks to the herringbone-patterned lining that adds a little extra pizazz.

Chanel Bleu De Chanel Eau de Toilette Cologne ($115-$180)

Because your next Nordstrom trip doesn't have to be solely about you — you can grab a little something special for your man, too. This cologne is effortlessly cool. It opens with bright grapefruit and lemon notes, warms up with a touch of ginger and nutmeg, and finishes with cedar, sandalwood, and a hint of incense. It smells fresh, clean, and masculine without trying too hard; which is exactly why I love it.

Glossier "You" Perfume ($82)

Glossier You is one of those gender neutral perfumes that just works. It's soft, warm, and a little musky, with notes of pink pepper and iris that melt into your skin and smell slightly different on everyone. It's not overpowering or "too much" — just your natural scent, but better. Basically, it's an easy Valentine's Day gift they'll actually wear on repeat.

Lola Blanket in Desert Dune ($275)

There's a reason celebrities like Selena Gomez, Kourtney Kardashian, and Alix Earle can't stop raving about Lola Blankets; they're that comfortable. Available in everything from baby and travel sizes to extra-large, there's one to fit the bed, couch, or even carry-on bag. Cozy enough for anyone, this is a gift you know they'll actually use.

Editor Quote: "Dare I say this is the most comfortable blanket I've ever curled up in? And yes, I went there. It's so buttery soft that I actually look forward to slamming my laptop shut, changing into pajamas, and cocooning myself until bedtime. And even then, I drag it in with me." — Haley Lyndes, shopping staff writer

Haley Lyndes is a shopping writer and editor with more than seven years of experience in the publishing space. Specializing in home and lifestyle, she covers everything from furniture and mattresses to beauty products and fitness gear. Her writing has appeared in BuzzFeed, Travel + Leisure, and Real Simple.