Signs Below Deck Season 12 Will Be Better Than Below Deck Sailing Yacht Season 5 (Will They Bring More Drama?)

The Below Deck franchise is setting sail once again with the highly anticipated Season 12, and fans are eager to see what new drama will unfold. Known for its mix of over-the-top affluence and, at times, amusing anarchy, the show promises to deliver plenty of unforgettable moments. With fresh charters and returning favorites, the original series seems ready to reclaim its title as the crown jewel of the franchise.

Meanwhile, as Below Deck Sailing Yacht season 5 finally docks for the season, many fans are left feeling underwhelmed by the show. Even though the setting is breathtaking scenery and high-end clientele continue to show out, the absence of compelling storylines has not gone unnoticed. Fans are counting on Below Deck season 12 packing the punch its sister show has been missing.

Below Deck Season 12 Is Allegedly Bringing Back These Fan Favorites

One of the most anticipated aspects of Below Deck season 12 is the return of beloved crew members from season 11. Chief Stew Fraser Olender, Deckhand Kyle Stillie, Chef Anthony Iracane, and Deckhand Sunny Marquis are allegedly returning, along with Captain Kerry Titheradge, who made a splash in his debut last season. Fraser's sharp wit and Kyle's contagious energy promise to keep the crew, charter guests, and fans entertained. The wild card appears to be Chef Anthony, who is eager to redeem himself after being fired mid-season in Season 11.

Sunny, particularly after being promoted to lead deckhand last season, brings a distinctive dynamic to the team. She delivers a great deal of professionalism, all while not taking herself all that seriously. Meanwhile, Captain Kerry's compassionate leadership style has won over fans, offering a renewed approach compared to his predecessor, Captain Lee Rosbach. Charm, conflict, and camaraderie are a guarantee in this must-watch lineup.

Below Deck Sailing Yacht Season 5 Has Been Lackluster

Below Deck Sailing Yacht season 5 is somewhat boring, and has struggled to hold the attention of its viewers, falling short of the franchise's typically high entertainment standards. The season has been marked by a prominent lack of significant scandals or heated conflicts between the crew, leaving fans craving the high-stakes drama that defines the series. While the show continues to deliver the best scenery on the seas, that is not enough to carry the season.

Fans tune in to the series for the unpredictable personal dynamics and explosive confrontations that make reality TV captivating. Unfortunately, this season has vastly failed to deliver such moments, leading to widespread disappointment. Fans are not holding back on social media about their dismay with this season. On X, @j0llyjill/ writes, "This seasons below deck sailing yacht is lowkey very boring." While @mechelle_EP comments, "Something is seriously wrong with these stews. They complain way TOO much. May they never grace the screen again after this season wraps up."

Without compelling storylines to anchor it, Below Deck Sailing Yacht season 5 can't seem to match the energy and excitement of its predecessors.

Gary King's Misconduct Hurt Below Deck Sailing Yacht Season 5

A huge factor contributing to Below Deck Sailing Yacht season 5's ho-hum reception is the controversy surrounding First Mate Gary King. Allegations of inappropriate behavior surfaced before the season aired, creating a weighty tone that overshadowed the show. Instead of focusing on the usual nonchalant drama, much of the conversation among fans shifted to addressing the gravity of these claims.

While Bravo and the production team made efforts to manage the situation, the fallout significantly impacted the season's overall appeal. Fans were left grappling with the stress between enjoying the show and processing the allegations against a key cast member. This unfortunate circumstance shifted attention from the series' chance to appeal to fans.

Below Deck Has Done Well Since Kerry Became Captain

One of the standout components of Below Deck is the renewed energy Captain Kerry brought to the series. He offers a hands-on approach to addressing incidents on the boat, along with a sense of fairness and humor. Under his command, season 11 showcased a balance of competence and chaos, with plenty of surprising twists that kept fans hooked.

Captain Kerry's uncanny ability to manage challenging personalities and navigate tense situations has earned him praise from fans and the crew. His leadership style facilitates authentic interactions, often leading to captivating storylines that make Below Deck a staple of reality TV. With him at the helm for season 12, fans can look forward to another exhilarating ride on the high seas.​

Sources:: Bravo, @j0llyjill/X, @mechelle_EP/X