Sigma and Tamron now make four bright standard zooms for APS-C mirrorless cameras, and choosing between the Sigma 17-40mm f/1.8, the Sigma 18-50mm f/2.8, the Tamron 16-50mm f/2.8, and the Tamron 17-70mm f/2.8 means trading aperture against reach, size, and stabilization. A standard zoom tends to live on your camera, so its strengths and weak spots show up in more of your pictures than those of any other lens you own.
When Christopher Frost puts all four lenses side by side, the first split he draws is on paper. The Sigma 17-40mm f/1.8 DC Art has the shortest range of the group. Its f/1.8 maximum aperture lets in more than twice the light of the others, which buys faster shutter speeds indoors and shallower depth of field, though focus gets a little less forgiving. The Tamron 17-70mm f/2.8 Di III-A VC RXD sits at the opposite end, with enough reach to frame a tight portrait while holding f/2.8 throughout. The Sigma 18-50mm f/2.8 DC DN Contemporary and the Tamron 16-50mm f/2.8 give up some of both in exchange for size: about 290 g and 305 g, against roughly 525 g for each of the bigger pair. All four come in Sony E, Canon RF, and Fujifilm X versions, with the Tamrons also on Nikon Z and the Sigmas also on L-Mount.
Frost finds the four nearly identical in construction. Each has a plastic barrel that still feels sturdy, basic weather-sealing with a gasket at the mount, and autofocus that is fast, accurate, and quiet. Third-party autofocus once had a reputation for hunting and missing, and none of these lenses carries that baggage. The smaller pair take 55 mm filters, the larger pair 67 mm, and all ship with plastic hoods. The one real hardware difference is stabilization, since only the Tamron 17-70mm has it built in. On a body without in-body stabilization, that lets you handhold stills at slower shutter speeds and keeps video noticeably smoother, especially at 70mm.
Frost left three similar lenses out of the comparison: Fujifilm's XF 16-55mm f/2.8 R LM WR II, Sony's E 16-55mm f/2.8 G, and Nikon's Z DX 16-50mm f/2.8 VR. Each works only on its maker's system, while these four Sigma and Tamron lenses cost less and cover several mounts. A seven-lens comparison, he adds, would have been a nightmare to watch, never mind edit.
Frost compares sharpness at a 26 MP view, a resolution common on Sony and Fujifilm APS-C bodies. At the wide end, wide open, every lens is close to razor sharp in the center, so the corners do the separating. The two small lenses show soft corners at f/2.8, while the larger pair look crisper, and once the Sigma 17-40mm is stopped down to the same f/2.8, it looks excellent. Stopping the small lenses to f/4 changes little. By f/5.6, they start to firm up, and at f/8, they're usable, with the Tamron 16-50mm holding a slight edge over the older Sigma 18-50mm.
In the middle of the zoom range, the Tamron 16-50mm is the weakest in the center wide open, with good resolution but much lower contrast, though by f/4, all four look really sharp. The corners there are far better than at the wide end, and by f/4, they all look fantastic, with the two Tamrons just a touch softer. Zoomed all the way in, only the Sigma 17-40mm is really good in the center wide open, the two Sigmas have the sharpest corners, and the Tamron 16-50mm adds extra color fringing in its corners. Across every focal length, Frost ranks the Sigma 17-40mm the sharpest by a considerable margin, followed by the Tamron 17-70mm and the Sigma 18-50mm, with the Tamron 16-50mm last, though not by much.
Vignetting and distortion barely separate the four. With in-camera corrections off, each one shows dark corners wide open and strong barrel distortion at its widest setting. Zoom in slightly, and the lines straighten out, then heavy pincushion distortion appears at the long end. Stopping down about two stops brings illumination close to even, and leaving in-camera corrections on cleans up the rest.
Up close, the order flips. Zoomed out, the little Sigma 18-50mm focuses extremely close and is really sharp there even at f/2.8, though shooting that close at the wide end is hard in practice. Zoomed in, all four get respectably close and all four struggle wide open, mostly with chromatic aberration, but this time, the Sigma 17-40mm and Tamron 17-70mm fare worst and the Tamron 16-50mm does best. They reach their best close-up quality at f/5.6, with some color fringing left. Against bright lights, the Sigma 17-40mm flares noticeably less than the others, apart from a broad circular reflection at wide angles when a light sits at a certain spot on the edge of the frame, while the Tamron 17-70mm holds up zoomed out but flares a lot zoomed in. For bokeh, the Tamron 17-70mm is probably the best, with impressively smooth backgrounds at both ends, the Sigma 17-40mm is averagely smooth, and the two small lenses look busy in the middle distance, with blue outlines on bright highlights.
His verdict follows from all that. The Sigma 18-50mm is the pick if you want the smallest, lightest, and cheapest option, the Tamron 16-50mm trades a little image quality for a wider angle, and the Sigma 17-40mm is worth saving for if you want the sharpest lens and the brightest aperture, as long as you can live without stabilization for handheld video. For most people, though, he'd recommend the Tamron 17-70mm, which is only slightly pricier than the small lenses and adds stabilization and a much longer zoom range. Overall, he'd save up for one of the two bigger lenses.
Frost's flare and bokeh samples from all four lenses come near the end of the video.

2 hours ago
5







English (US) ·