Sarah Michelle Gellar Reveals Surprising Freddie Prinze Jr. Connection

2 hours ago 18

Sarah Michelle Gellar Shares Surprising Connection Between Her, Freddie Prinze Jr.’s Families

Now this is a revelation to wig out over.

Sarah Michelle Gellar and Freddie Prinze Jr.’s paths didn’t officially cross until the late ‘90s on I Know What You Did Last Summer, but as they recently learned they had more in common than they realized. Specifically, a shared family experience that traces back decades before they graced the screen. 

“We always joke that the closest connection I had to my husband's side of the family,” Gellar told E! News in an exclusive interview, “was that for a small time I went to the same high school that my husband's dad went to, and that was like sort of our one thing.”

After all, though Gellar—mom to Charlotte, 17, and Rocky, 14, with Prinze—is a native New Yorker, her husband was born in Los Angeles and grew up in New Mexico. (His dad Freddie Prinze, however, hailed from New York.)

She continued, “Then through Ancestry, we found out that our grandparents lived less than two miles away from each other in the Bronx at one point, which they could have potentially known each other. That's kind of crazy.” 

For the Buffy the Vampire Slayer star, who teamed up with Ancestry for its Gathering the Good initiative, it was an opportunity to explore her own family’s legacy while also looking at the spirit of giving through history. So, tracing how her loved ones made the journey to America in the 1890s at the same time philanthropist Lena Sittig space was creating what is now considered to be the modern toy drive, really hit home how interconnected the mission is.

Courtesy of Sarah Michelle Gellar

“I learned that my grandmother was coming over on a ship at 16 years old, right when Lena was having her idea for this,” she shared. “It’s kind of crazy how the world intertwines, and it just reminds you that you're just such a small part of such a bigger picture.”

It’s especially poignant as diving back into her roots has not always been a focal point for Gellar.

“It's funny, I didn't really spend that much time thinking about my history and my ancestry because I try so hard to live in the moment,” she explained. “And when Ancestry came to me and talked about what they wanted to do, I thought, ‘What a great idea to be able to learn acts of kindness, acts of goodness that your family may have been a part of that you never knew.’”

As the Cruel Intentions alum knows, ‘tis the season to pay it forward. “The holiday season gets so dramatic—presents and all that,” she noted. “And I always look for what are the things that you could give someone that are really meaningful.”

So, the 49-year-old posited, “What's more meaningful than learning about where you came from and your family and things you may not have known?”

To Gellar, it all comes back to Lena Sittig and her Brooklyn Christmas Tree Society, and how her idea is sparking change so many generations later. In fact, the Ringer actress teamed up with Ancestry to fulfill Christmas lists for Children’s Aid. 

AP/Sara Kerens

“So often, I think we think, ‘Well, I'm one person. What can I do?’ And then you see something like that, and you realize, oh wow, one person can do a lot,” she told E!. “But then to take it that step further, and maybe there's people in her family had no idea they were related to her.” 

“Can you imagine going back in your history and finding out that one person in your family was responsible for millions of children's gifts all over the world because they had this idea?” Gellar added. “I think it's really special.”

And it’s an experience Gellar wants to send far and wide, teasing what many of her loved ones—not to mention anyone looking to explore the impact their family has made on others—may be getting under the tree this year.

“There's something for me about the how tangible it was,” she admitted. “I saw signatures, I saw writing. it makes it seem just much more real to you than just getting an email that says, ‘You know you came from here’ like, seeing their actual signatures at Ellis Island. It's also something too, growing up in New York City, you forget about it. But this is the gateway.”

And for Gellar it also ended up being a sweet gateway into a piece of history she and Prinze didn’t realize they shared. For a deeper history of the longtime couple’s life together, keep reading…

Eric Charbonneau/Sony Pictures via Getty Images

I Know What You Did on Date Night

Sarah Michelle Gellar and Freddie Prinze Jr. turned the clocks back to 1997 at the July 2025 premiere of the latest I Know What You Did Last Summer movie.

Sarah Michelle Gellar/Instagram

Travel Buddies for Life

Gellar commemorated "another successful trip" on Instagram in April 2024 with a sweet selfie.

Jerod Harris/Getty Images for Knott's Scary Farm

Not Scary Outing

They were all smiles as they marked the 50th anniversary of Knott's Scary Farm in 2023.

Instagram/Sarah Michelle Gellar

Feeling Merry

They were feeling especially festive in 2022, slaying the Christmas game with their chic glasses.

Instagram

Party of Four

In January 2019, they had a double date with Shannen Doherty and the actress' then-husband Kurt Iswarienko.

Instagram

Kiss Kiss

"No mistletoe, no problem," the mom of two wrote on this December 2018 kissy photo.

Instagram

Halloween Hotties

In 2018, the lovebirds took their Halloween costumes to the next level by dressing up as characters from The Royal Tenenbaums. 

Instagram

Blissful

It doesn't matter what these two do, as long as they're together they are having a good time.

Instagram

Ice Cream Cuddles

"If you were ice cream, you would be my favorite flavor," Gellar captioned this sweet snap in 2018.

Instagram

Wine Not?

"It's the freakin weekend, baby I'm about to have me some fun," Gellar wrote on this cheeky post in March of 2018.

Instagram

Photo Booth Fun

In December 2017, the cute couple had some fun at an engagement party thanks to photo booth props.

Instagram

Pretty in Pink

Gellar channeled her inner Molly Ringwald with her Andie costume from Pretty in Pink in 2017 while her husband nailed it as Duckie (played by Jon Cryer) from the film.

Instagram

Sparks Will Fly

"The only time I don't mind giving up #independence lol," Gellar joked to her followers on the 4th of July in 2017.

Instagram

Ready, Set, Smile

The couple that snaps selfies together, stays together! 

Instagram

Birthday Lovin'

Gellar's birthday message in 2017 to her husband was just the cutest. "Happy birthday @realfreddieprinze," she wrote, "'the happiest people don't have the best of everything, they just make the best of everything.'"

Instagram

Hearts Full

In January 2017, the pair celebrated National Spouse Day by taking this pic.

Instagram

Red Hot

"Someone let me know who that red head was seen trick or treating with @realfreddieprinze ..." Gellar joked on Instagram while celebrating Halloween in 2016.

Instagram

Beachin'

The Scooby-Doo stars soaked up the last bits of summer together in 2016.

Instagram

Proud as Can Be

The Buffy the Vampire Slayer alum couldn't help but gush about her husband after his cookbook came out.

Instagram

Movie Night

"Finally out like the adults we are...to see #fantasticalbeastsandwheretofindthem," Gellar revealed while out on a date night in November 2016.

Instagram

Fight Club

In October 2015, the duo posed with wrestling belts and tried to out muscle each other.

Instagram

Friends Forever

The bond between Gellar, Prinze and Selma Blair has lasted for three decades and we can't wait to see what they do during the next three.

Instagram

Baby on Board

In this adorable throwback, Gellar revealed that the couple took this photo in Hawaii after they learned they were expecting their daughter Charlotte!

Instagram

Dirty 30

These two have had a lot of fun in their relationship, and the Foodstirs creator's "Dirty 30" birthday party was no exception. 

Instagram

Gobble, Gobble, Gobble

This throwback snap, the happy couple celebrated their first Thanksgiving together.

Instagram

Beach Babies

The I Know What You Did Last Summer costars looked like babies in this photo from a vacation way back before they had kids together.

Instagram

Sunsets Forever

We just love these two.

Instagram

Christmas Cuties

If you've ever wanted to know what Prinze and Gellar looked like when celebrating their first holiday together, then look no further!

Instagram

Drunk in Love

How happy do these two lovebirds look in this sweet photo from their honeymoon back in 2002?!

Instagram

Just Married

Clearly, this pair was a match made in smiley heaven.

For the latest breaking news updates, click here to download the E! News App

Read Entire Article