The Library of Congress copy is an albumen print on a card mount, with a torn typed label beneath it. Theodore Roosevelt stands at its center in suspenders and a spotted neckerchief, a torn American flag behind him, with dozens of men from the 1st U.S. Volunteer Cavalry packed around him on bare, sandy ground. The Library catalogs it as "Colonel Roosevelt and his Rough Riders at the top of the hill which they captured, Battle of San Juan," credits William Dinwiddie, and dates it 1898.
Captions have long placed the scene on San Juan Hill just after the charge of July 1, 1898. Newer ones move it to Kettle Hill, the lower rise the Rough Riders took first, date it to about July 3, and say a wider version that showed Black troopers of the 10th U.S. Cavalry was cut down to Roosevelt and his own regiment.
A wider picture does exist, and Roosevelt's own book printed it in 1899. A second flag stands at its right edge over a knot of standing soldiers, and at the far edge a Black regular looks straight into the lens. It is a separate exposure, apparently from the same sitting, not an uncropped original. Captions in Roosevelt's book and in an album Dinwiddie gave him in 1902 put both pictures at San Juan, and the album has the men "on the trenches," the line the Rough Riders dug after the charge. None mentions Kettle Hill, and no document gives the day either picture was made.
What Dinwiddie Called It in 1898
The catalog title is the Library's own. Its Library of Congress record says "Title devised by Library staff." What survives of the label reads "at the top of the hill which they captured," then the words "of San Juan," then "By William Dinwiddie. 1898." The surviving words match a title in the Copyright Office's printed catalog. On September 17, 1898, Dinwiddie registered "Teddy's colts at the top of the hill which they captured in the battle of San Juan" as registration no. 54581.
The famous print is no. 15 of 15 Santiago prints by Dinwiddie that the Library keeps as one lot, catalogued as a copyright deposit from 1898 and sized 15 by 12 inches. Truth, the New York magazine that ran his war sketches, advertised his mounted originals in Leslie's Weekly on October 13, 1898, listing five subjects that came postpaid with a $2.50 subscription and others at $5.00 each. Each print was signed, mounted on heavy board, and 15 by 12 inches. The ad called Dinwiddie "the only photographer who was actually present on the firing line during the three days' fight."
Dinwiddie was 30 at Santiago. Born in Charlottesville, Virginia, on August 23, 1867, he had worked from 1886 to 1895 as an assistant archaeologist at the Bureau of American Ethnology before moving into journalism. Harper's Weekly printed his photographs of the July 1 fighting, including one of Captain Capron's battery at El Caney, in its August 6, 1898, issue. He went on to report from the Philippines for the New York Herald and Harper's Weekly, later served as governor of the province of Lepanto-Bontoc there, and died in 1934.
Two Hills and One Name
The Cavalry Division fought dismounted on July 1, 1898. Roosevelt, a lieutenant colonel, commanded the Rough Riders that day because Colonel Leonard Wood had been moved up to lead the brigade. Ahead of them was a hill topped by ranch buildings. Roosevelt wrote that they "afterward grew to call Kettle Hill," and he described "a huge iron kettle, or something of the kind, probably used for sugar refining" on its top. The San Juan ridge ran beyond it, with its main blockhouse off to the cavalry's left, where the infantry attacked.
Roosevelt's 1899 account puts his regiment, the 9th Cavalry, and the 1st Cavalry on Kettle Hill, with the 3rd, 6th, and 10th going "partly up Kettle Hill" and partly toward the blockhouse. He wrote that Sergeant George Berry of the 10th carried his own regiment's colors and the 3rd's up the slope after the 3rd's color sergeant was shot down. From the crest, Roosevelt led a mixed force on to the ridge itself, while Samuel S. Sumner, who had taken over the division from the ailing General Joseph Wheeler, kept a reserve on Kettle Hill.
Sumner described the rest in a 1905 letter that Roosevelt printed in his 1913 autobiography. The Rough Riders passed a small lake and came over the ridge opposite a frame house ringed by an earthwork, "not Fort San Juan proper," then took "an irregular semi-circular position along the ridge" just to its right, with part of the 10th Cavalry around the house. Later that day and the next, Sumner wrote, the division's regiments were rearranged by brigade along the ridge, and that became "the position occupied by the Cavalry Division until the final surrender of the Spanish forces, on July 17, 1898."
Dinwiddie photographed Kettle Hill from that ridge and registered the view on September 22, 1898, as "The hill from which the dismounted cavalry division charged San Juan hill before Santiago, July 1st, 1898." The album of his Santiago prints that he gave Roosevelt on April 22, 1902, now in Harvard's Theodore Roosevelt Collection, captions the same view "Looking back from San Juan trenches toward Kettle Hill." It captions the famous group "Colonel Roosevelt and his men on the trenches in front of Santiago. At the point on San Juan Hill first reached by the Rough Riders in their charge."
Harvard notes that the album's captions are in an unknown hand. The inscription inside the cover is in Dinwiddie's: "From a man who, during the Santiago Campaign, made a few photographs from safe positions, to a man whom he admires as a genius in war and a statesman in peace." Mark Lee Gardner, in his 2016 history of the regiment, notes that "San Juan Hill was a long rolling ridge with more than one blockhouse," and that the name later narrowed to the stretch around the San Juan blockhouse.
The Wider Frame in Roosevelt's Book
Roosevelt serialized "The Rough Riders" in Scribner's Magazine from January to June 1899. The May 1899 installment, "In the Trenches," carried a full-page plate turned sideways on page 571, captioned "Colonel Roosevelt and Rough Riders at the Point where they Charged Over the Hill at San Juan." The same plate faces page 168 of the book Scribner's published that year. Neither printing credits a photographer. A print of the same view sits in Dinwiddie's 1902 album, captioned "Colonel Roosevelt and his Rough Riders on the trenches, San Juan Hill," and Harvard describes the album as photographs "presumably taken chiefly by Dinwiddie."
The camera stands farther back than in the famous frame. A raw trench and its parapet cut across the foreground. Roosevelt, in the same suspenders and neckerchief, stands near the center under a flag on a tall upright staff, with men massed to the left and seated along the parapet in front of him. On the right, a second flag rises over a knot of standing soldiers, and at the far edge a Black trooper looks straight into the lens.
Dan Moos singled out that man in his 2005 book "Outside America," calling him "a black regular." Gardner reproduced the album print in 2016 with a caption identifying the men on either side of the Rough Riders as "members of the Third and Tenth U.S. Cavalries, who shared the American line with them on San Juan Hill." He does not say which regiment stood on which side. He dates the picture with a hedge: "Probably photographed on July 3, 1898, following the truce."
The 10th Cavalry Shared the Trench Line
No caption from 1898 or 1899 names the soldiers at the right edge of the wider frame. Richard Harding Davis's "The Cuban and Porto Rican Campaigns," published by Scribner's in 1898, includes a different photograph, titled "The Trenches of the Rough Riders on San Juan Hill," with two flags planted on the parapet. Its caption reads, "The flag on the right belongs to the Tenth Colored Regulars." Roosevelt's own book places "Captain Ayres of the Tenth Cavalry on the right of my line" during a night of Spanish fire, when Ayres "bade his black troopers cease firing."
The 10th's own officers put some of its men in Roosevelt's trenches. First Lieutenant E. D. Anderson, commanding Troop C, wrote on July 5, 1898, that Roosevelt and part of his regiment had joined his line on its right on July 1, and that "that night my troop and Troop I intrenched and held the trenches during July 2 and 3." The War Department later printed his report. Sergeant Presley Holliday of Troop B put the 10th's strength with Roosevelt at "about one troop," alongside a few men from the 9th and 1st Cavalry. Sumner and Anderson place 10th troopers on the Rough Riders' left on July 1, before the lines were rearranged, while Roosevelt's Ayres passage and Davis's caption put the 10th on their right.
Roosevelt wrote that the 10th lost "a greater proportion of its officers than any other regiment in the battle," 11 of its 22. Lieutenant John J. Pershing, the 10th's quartermaster, told a Chicago church audience on November 27, 1898, how the regiments had fought on July 1. "White regiments, black regiments, regulars and Rough Riders, representing the young manhood of the North and the South, fought shoulder to shoulder, unmindful of race or color," Pershing said.
A Second Exposure, Not a Crop
Online, the wider picture often circulates with a caption saying the famous version crops out everyone but Roosevelt and his regiment. The two frames do not line up that way. The wide view was made from farther back, its main flag hangs from a vertical staff where the famous one leans on a slanted pole, and the trench in its foreground does not appear in the famous frame at all. Because the camera moved, neither picture can be trimmed out of the other. Prints of the famous negative do vary in width. A looser print held by the Theodore Roosevelt Birthplace National Historic Site shows a few more men at each side than the Library's copy, and it still has one flag.
Moos described the book's plate as "a slightly different photograph from the same session, likely taken only minutes before or after the more famous shot." He pointed to other Black soldiers in the wider view, including two men midway between Roosevelt and the left margin, and argued that the tighter photograph "is distinctly cropped near these men." He suggested a desire "to present Roosevelt as a heroic figure rather than merely one soldier among many and to exclude black faces." That is Moos's reading of the composition. Dinwiddie left no known explanation of how he framed either picture.
No caption, letter, or registration gives the day of that session. The Rough Riders were under fire on the ridge through July 2 and the morning of July 3. "At twelve o'clock we were notified to stop firing and a flag of truce was sent in to demand the surrender of the city," Roosevelt wrote of July 3. Gardner ties his July 3 date to that truce.
The regiment was ordered to embark on August 6 and sailed the next morning on the transport Miami, so a picture of it on the ridge was made before then. The registration that matches the famous frame's label is dated September 17. The Library's 1975 picture book "Viewpoints" captioned it "at the Top of San Juan Hill after Its Capture, July 1898." When The Outlook printed it on June 27, 1908, with the credit "Photograph by William Dinwiddie," it ran above a poem titled "On the Hill (July 1, 1898)."
What Roosevelt Wrote About the 10th
In September 1898, Roosevelt praised the Black regiments in public. A letter from Roosevelt printed in the Cleveland Gazette on September 10 said, "The Ninth and Tenth Cavalry regiments fought one on each side of mine at Santiago and I wish no better men beside me in battle than these colored troops showed themselves to be." It went on, "Later on when I come to write of the campaign I shall have much to say about them."
On September 13, at Camp Wikoff on Montauk, the regiment presented Roosevelt with a bronze bronco buster inside a hollow square that, by The Sun's account, held 500 Rough Riders and "200 men from the Ninth and Tenth cavalry." In his reply, Roosevelt turned to "some of the men I see standing around not of your number." "The Spaniards called them 'Smoked Yankees,' but we found them to be an excellent breed of Yankee," he said.
The April 1899 installment in Scribner's, "The Cavalry at Santiago," described "perhaps a score of colored infantrymen" in Roosevelt's mixed line on the ridge on the afternoon of July 1. It said that "no troops could have behaved better than the colored soldiers had behaved so far," then called them "peculiarly dependent upon their white officers." When some of these men began "to drift to the rear," Roosevelt wrote, he drew his revolver and told them "that I should shoot the first man who, on any pretence whatever, went to the rear." The same installment credited Berry and the 10th's officer losses.
Sergeant Holliday answered in a letter dated April 22, 1899, at Fort Ringgold, Texas, which the New York Age printed on May 11. "All the colored troops in that command were cavalrymen," he wrote. He said two of the men had been sent to the rear by Lieutenant Fleming of the 10th to bring rations or entrenching tools, and that Roosevelt came to the 10th's line the next day to say "he had seen his mistake and found them to be far different men from what he supposed."
Holliday called the published statement "uncalled for and uncharitable" and said it "has done us an immeasurable lot of harm." In May 1899, one installment after the revolver passage, Scribner's printed the wider frame across a full page. Its caption names only Roosevelt and the Rough Riders, though a second flag stands at the right edge. The frame that became famous has only one flag in it.
Lead image by William Dinwiddie, public domain. Source.

19 hours ago
62







English (US) ·