PC Gamer's highest review scores of 2024

14 hours ago 2
 ReFantazio
(Image credit: Atlus)

On the one hand, "score inflation" is a real concern we discuss. We think a game should have to be really special to receive a 90%, so when we start talking about a 94% or a 95%, the game in question ought to make us feel like the guy in the galaxy brain meme with light beams shooting out of his head. As a group, we've still never awarded a score higher than 98%, and the pages of PC Gamer's UK edition have yet to see a score above 97%, which was only given last year to Baldur's Gate 3. PC Gamer is 30 years old.

On the other hand, sometimes your reviewers come to you and say, look, I know this has the appearance of an ASCII game from the '80s, but it's amazing, incredible, fantastic, brilliant. 94%! And you ask them some questions, and ask other editors what they think, and play it for yourself a bit, and a little while later you're doing a water ritual with a guy named Abbashaphat Mordecai which causes your reputation with "newly sentient beings" to decrease, and so you decide, alright: 94% it is.

Sometimes the games are just good. That was true a lot this year.

Of course, a score is just shorthand for how a reviewer felt about a game, and lots of games don't get high scores from us even though plenty of people think they're brilliant, including people at PC Gamer. Most games don't get a score from us at all, because we can't possibly review everything, and don't typically score early access games. In other words, this is not a comprehensive list of the best games of the year, and in fact some of our 2024 GOTY Award winners aren't on it. And yet it's still a pretty big list. 2024 perhaps wasn't the splashiest year for PC gaming, but bad? Definitely not.

Here are PC Gamer's highest review scores of 2024:

89%

Lili in Tekken 8.

(Image credit: Bandai Namco)
  • Persona 3 Reload: "a highly-polished remake of the 2006 classic"
  • Tekken 8: "The best Tekken game in years, let down only by its struggling netcode and aged customization"
  • Dragon's Dogma 2: "A magnificent adventure with impressive fights and some very rough edges"
  • V Rising: "An even better version of one of the best Early Access survival games"
  • Little Kitty, Big City: "an adorable, entertaining journey through a delightful world that's just the right size"
  • Lorelai and the Laser Eyes: "a thrilling mystery that asks players to rise to its challenges, and rewards them when they do"

90%

Satisfactory

(Image credit: Coffee Stain)
  • Microsoft Flight Simulator 2024: "fulfills the promise of being the most true-to-life and detailed game of its kind"
  • Shogun Showdown: "This wonderfully clever strategy roguelike demands your best, and it deserves to get it"
  • Diablo 4: Vessel of Hatred: "Compelling characters to root for, creative loot to chase, and fiercely expressive action"
  • Satisfactory: "a masterfully made game for crafters, builders, and factory managers of all kinds"
  • Riven: "as impressive, immersive, and unmissable as it's ever been"
  • Animal Well: "a sleep-destroying puzzle metroidvania of baffling depth"
  • Granblue Fantasy: Relink: "an essential ARPG"

91%

Assaulting a fort

(Image credit: Blue Manchu)
  • Dragon Quest 3 HD-2D Remake: "welcoming for newcomers, a fan's dream, and a truly timeless classic"
  • Shin Megami Tensei 5: Vengeance: “combines the fresh, familiar, and the fiendish into one incredible RPG”
  • Wild Bastards: "The roguelike and FPS genres haven't been spliced so successfully since Deathloop"
  • Balatro: "A roguelike deckbuilder debut already worthy of joining Slay the Spire and Monster Train at the King’s table. Essential"

92%

Destiny 2 The Final Shape release times - Prismatic warlock

(Image credit: Bungie)
  • Destiny 2: The Final Shape: "It's simply the best Destiny 2 expansion—both a satisfying conclusion to the series' first saga, and a compelling shooter packed full of stuff to do"
  • Factorio: Space Age: "Blowing out Factorio’s scale and reinventing its factory systems multiple times over, Space Age is an immediate contender for the best expansion ever made"

94%

Caves of Qud

(Image credit: Freehold Games)
  • Caves of Qud: "a genre-defining achievement in play, story, and roleplaying freedom"

95%

 ReFantazio

(Image credit: Atlus)

Keep up to date with the most important stories and the best deals, as picked by the PC Gamer team.

Tyler grew up in Silicon Valley during the '80s and '90s, playing games like Zork and Arkanoid on early PCs. He was later captivated by Myst, SimCity, Civilization, Command & Conquer, all the shooters they call "boomer shooters" now, and PS1 classic Bushido Blade (that's right: he had Bleem!). Tyler joined PC Gamer in 2011, and today he's focused on the site's news coverage. His hobbies include amateur boxing and adding to his 1,200-plus hours in Rocket League.

Read Entire Article