Lies of P: Overture is so good it makes me want to do countless New Game Plus runs to experience it over and over again

After two long years of waiting, Lies of P: Overture has finally arrived.

A full-sized expansion to the 2023 base game (a title that was my game of the year for 2023), Overture is a masterful example of taking an already complete-feeling game and showing that its best content was actually yet to come. Indeed, if Lies of P wasn’t already one of the best soulslike games out there, it certainly is now.

Overture is a prequel set some years before the events of Lies of P. The protagonist and his companion Gemini somehow find themselves transported back in time, right on the cusp of the Puppet Frenzy outbreak and the spread of the Petrification Disease. You’ll visit locations that have since been burned to the ground or decommissioned, and meet a handful of characters whose fates are only discussed in passing in the base game.

If you’re a lore head, then you’ll be pretty pleased with Overture, as it fills in the gaps left by plenty of unanswered questions - and sheds even further light on the twisted experiments and excursions of the villainous Alchemist faction.

You can also expect to visit plenty of gorgeous locations, including the opening level of Krat Zoo and its massive greenhouse and carnival. There are a handful of underground interiors that can start to feel a little samey, and there are some instances of very questionable enemy placement (those guys dual-wielding massive shields can absolutely do one) but the good news is that level design is as strong here as it is in the main campaign.

Naturally, Overture also sets the stage for plenty of new boss fights, and these are by far the best and most challenging encounters the whole game has to offer. Paired with the brand new Battle Memories mode - which lets you replay all bosses across five difficulty levels - and there’s plenty to keep fans busy here for months if not years to come.

At around 20-25 hours, I estimate Overture to be roughly half as long as the base game on a first playthrough on the Legendary Stalker difficulty (that’s the game’s standard difficulty option, joined by two easier modes in the accompanying free update). Though it is possible you may run the clock a bit longer than that if you’re stuck on some of these boss fights or going through the new lore with a fine-toothed comb.

Overall, though, if you liked Lies of P, you’ll adore the Overture expansion. Developer Round8 Studio seems to have already perfected its approach to the soulslike formula, and I’m beyond excited to see what the team has in store for the future.

Pasts unwritten

Firstly, I’d just like to note how simple it is to unlock and play the Overture DLC. So long as you’ve beaten Chapter 9 of the main story, you’ll get an item and a prompt telling you exactly where to go to begin the expansion. There’s no FromSoftware-esque obscurity here; just head to said location and you’re underway in seconds, which is very welcome.

If you’re curious about how the Overture journey begins, you can read my preview where I talk about Krat Zoo at length. Otherwise, I won’t get into a talk about the expansion’s individual levels for the sake of avoiding spoilers. But in general, you can expect the same compact, expertly crafted level design for the most part. Overture still follows the fairly linear level structure of the main game, but there are plenty of avenues of exploration and instances of revisiting earlier levels during side quests.

You’ll absolutely want to be exploring these locations top to bottom, too. Overture has no shortage of new weapons, costumes, consumables, scraps of lore, sidequests, and even a couple of new Legion Arms (your trusty left arm-mounted utility) for you to discover.

The new weapons are pretty excellent across the board, and you can expect armaments obtained from each boss, as well as ones you’ll find tucked away in treasure chests that let you swap blade and hilt, just like in the base game. Better yet, these are compatible with the base game’s weapons, opening up even more opportunities for customization.

I went into Overture with a Technique (dexterity) build, so I quickly warmed to the new Death’s Talons weapon. These Wolverine-like claws slash foes quickly, and its unique Fable Art (special moves you can perform by filling the accompanying gauge) attack can perform a devastating multi-stage combo which quickly builds an enemy’s Stagger bar, allowing you to go in for a massive critical hit.

Pale Knight is another big winner; essentially a Squall Leonhart-esque gunblade with explosive rounds, it packs a serious punch for Motivity (strength) builds, and it’s one I can see becoming a favorite among the playerbase if only for its coolness factor.

Those two new Legion Arms are also a vast improvement over many of the main game’s roster. In Lies of P, most Legion Arms had very situational usages, making it tough to commit to a single one. Overture’s are far more practical, one producing a devastating shotgun blast, with the other firing out spinning discs that stay in place, damaging enemies over a short period of time.

Both are vastly more useful, and I find myself sticking with the latter in particular for my current New Game Plus run.

Writ in blood

It wouldn’t be a soulslike experience without a few bosses for you to bash your head against for hours on end, and Lies of P: Overture certainly doesn’t disappoint in this department. While there aren’t too many new boss encounters, the ones that are here are absolutely a quality over quantity affair.

I’ve already spoken at length about three of them in my previous boss impressions piece - and I certainly won’t be spoiling the remainder here - but you can rest assured that if you’re seeking a challenge, Overture’s bosses are indisputably the hardest fights in the entire game.

Hard, but certainly not unfair. And if you’re tired of those Elden Ring-style bosses that have seemingly endless combo strings, there’s actually very little of that here. Like the main game, it’s all about pattern recognition and how effectively you can Perfect Guard the attacks you’re confident about, and dodging through the ones you’re not. Most of the bosses are a good deal speedier, too, so picking the right moments to strike is more crucial than ever here.

Should I play Lies of P: Overture?

Play it if...

Don't buy it if...

Accessibility

Lies of P: Overture has launched alongside a new free update for the game. This adds two easier difficulty options, perfect for players less versed in the soulslike experience. There are also new colorblind mode options (protanopia, deuteranopia, and tritanopia), as well as a colorblind mode intensity slider.

How I reviewed Lies of P: Overture

My playthrough of Lies of P: Overture took me around 20-25 hours to complete on the default Legendary Stalker difficulty. That time was spent combing through most of each level’s optional secrets and side quests, as well as a good deal of time up against the incredibly tough new boss encounters. While I’m not sure I achieved a 100% complete run, I am confident that I got to experience the vast majority of what Overture has to offer.

I played the expansion on PC (via Steam) with my controller of choice being the Razer Wolverine V3 Pro. I also made use of my RIG 900 Max HS gaming headset to experience the game’s immaculate soundtrack and impressive audio design.

First reviewed June 2025