Lee Harvey Oswald Called the Backyard Rifle Photos Fakes, but 11 Marks on the Negative Matched His Camera

1 hour ago 8

In Warren Commission Exhibit 133-A, Lee Harvey Oswald stands beside a wooden stairway in a Dallas backyard with a pistol holstered at his right hip. He holds a rifle in his left hand and two left-wing newspapers against his chest in his right. His wife, Marina, took the picture with an inexpensive American box camera in the spring of 1963. The National Archives posts an enlargement of it, along with a second pose, in its online JFK photo gallery.

Oswald called the pictures fakes. On the evening of November 23, 1963, a day after President John F. Kennedy was shot in Dealey Plaza, Capt. J. W. Fritz of the Dallas police showed him an enlargement made by the department's crime lab. Fritz wrote in his report on the interrogations that Oswald "said the picture was not his, that the face was his face, but that this picture had been made by someone superimposing his face, the other part of the picture was not him at all and that he had never seen the picture before."

Two government investigations tested that claim against the camera itself. In 1964, an FBI photography expert matched the only original negative investigators received to Oswald's Imperial Reflex. In 1978, a panel of the House Select Committee on Assassinations found 11 identifying marks along the negative's edge that corresponded to test pictures from Oswald's camera, while two other cameras of the same model left markedly different edges. The panel also checked the pictures with shadow geometry, stereo viewing, and photogrammetry.

President John F. Kennedy and Jacqueline Kennedy arrive at Dallas Love Field on November 22, 1963, less than an hour before he was shot in Dealey Plaza. Photo by Cecil Stoughton (White House), public domain. Source.

Two Prints and a Negative in Ruth Paine's Garage

The Oswalds rented an upstairs apartment at 214 West Neely Street in Dallas from the first days of March 1963 until April 24. Marina testified that on a Sunday, while she was hanging diapers, her husband asked her to photograph him with the rifle, the pistol, and two newspapers, which the commission later identified as the Militant and the Worker. At the time, Oswald was a photoprint trainee at Jaggars-Chiles-Stovall, a Dallas graphic arts company that had hired him in October 1962. It let him go on April 6, 1963.

The Warren Commission dated the pictures from the props. The rifle and the revolver, mail-ordered from Chicago and Los Angeles, both shipped on March 20. The two newspapers carried dates of March 11 and March 24, and postal authorities estimated that both would have reached Dallas by March 28. Marina remembered a Sunday about two weeks before the April 10 shot fired at Gen. Edwin Walker, so the commission settled on Sunday, March 31, 1963. Her accounts varied on the date and on whether she took one picture or two. Oswald's mother, Marguerite, testified that she and Marina destroyed another picture after the assassination, which she said showed him holding the rifle over his head.

Warren Commission Exhibit 133-A, one of the backyard photographs Marina Oswald took in March 1963, with Oswald holding the rifle and two newspapers and wearing a pistol at his hip. Photo by Marina Oswald, public domain. Source.

According to the Warren Report, Oswald gave Marina one of the prints to keep for their daughter, June. On the afternoon of November 23, Dallas detectives searched Ruth Paine's house in Irving, where Marina had been living, and Detective Guy F. Rose found a cardboard box of papers and photographs in the garage. The Warren Report lists two prints of Oswald with the rifle and a negative of 133-B among the finds, and it says the 133-A negative was never recovered. The House committee's photographic report says the box held two negatives, one of which has never been accounted for.

Ruth Paine's former house at 2515 West Fifth Street in Irving, Texas, in 2015. Dallas detectives found the backyard prints in a box in its garage on November 23, 1963. Photo by Timcdfw, CC BY-SA 4.0. Source.

What Oswald Told His Interrogators

Nobody recorded Oswald's interrogations on tape or in shorthand, so his denial survives only in the reports of the men in the room. Fritz wrote that Oswald said he "knew all about photography" and had worked a great deal in the field himself, and that he called the small print a reduction of the enlargement, made by someone he did not know. Oswald told Fritz "that in time, he would be able to show that it was not his picture," the report says.

FBI Special Agent James W. Bookhout reported that Oswald allowed that the head in the picture could be his but said the police might have superimposed it on someone else's body. Secret Service Inspector Thomas J. Kelley wrote that Oswald sneered at the pictures and said the police had photographed him the day before and then added a rifle and a gun. Oswald never made the argument in court, because Jack Ruby shot him in the basement of Dallas police headquarters the next morning.

Oswald's Dallas police booking photograph, taken November 23, 1963. Photo by the Dallas Police Department, public domain. Source.

Life put one of the pictures on its February 21, 1964, cover. James Martin, then Marina's business manager, told the Warren Commission that Life had paid $5,000 for the North American rights, though he had never had the photograph himself. Lyndal Shaneyfelt, the FBI photography expert who examined the evidence for the Warren Commission, testified that the published versions differed because each publication had retouched its copy. Critics went on to challenge the chin, the shadows, the head sizes, and the backgrounds.

The FBI Matched the Negative to the Camera in 1964

An FBI report on the camera's ownership traces how it reached investigators three months after the assassination. An Irving police detective, John A. McCabe, said he had taken a light gray box camera out of one of Oswald's boxes during the November 23 search, judged it of no evidentiary value, and put it back. The Dallas detectives said they never saw it. Robert Oswald collected his brother's belongings from the Paine garage in December and gave the FBI a Duo-Lens Imperial Reflex on February 24, 1964. Marina identified it the next day.

It was a cheap camera with fixed focus, a single shutter speed, and square 2¼-inch frames on 620 roll film. Shaneyfelt exposed a fresh negative in it and compared that frame's borders with those of Exhibit 749, the 133-B negative, under a microscope. The edge of every frame is a shadow of the camera's film aperture, the opening the film lies against, and those edges, though they look straight, are irregular. Shaneyfelt called that edge a shadowgraph and testified that every camera of this type makes its own.

Commission Exhibit 751, a 1964 photograph of Oswald's Imperial Reflex with its back removed. The square opening is the film-plane aperture, and the red arrows point to its edges, which print their irregularities onto the border of every frame. Photo by the FBI for the Warren Commission, public domain. Source.

Asked whether the method resembled toolmark identification, Shaneyfelt answered, "Very similar; yes," according to the Warren Report's account of his testimony. He concluded that Exhibit 749 had been exposed in Oswald's camera "to the exclusion of all other cameras," in the report's words. He found no sign of a composite in either print, with one reservation: "I cannot entirely eliminate an extremely expert composite." Faking 133-B, he said, would have meant pasting up a print, retouching it, and rephotographing the result in this particular camera without a trace, which he placed "in the realm of the impossible."

Detail of Commission Exhibit 753, a 1964 FBI comparison chart. This half is a print from a test negative Shaneyfelt exposed in Oswald's camera on the Justice Building's roof in Washington, where an FBI employee, his head blanked out, held the rifle found in the Texas School Book Depository. Arrows numbered 1 through 8 mark points on the frame edge, and the chart's other half marks the same eight points on a print from the backyard negative. Photo by the FBI for the Warren Commission, public domain. Source.

Eleven Edge Marks and Two Cameras From George Eastman House

Calvin S. McCamy, a former National Bureau of Standards scientist, and Sgt. Cecil W. Kirk of the Washington, D.C., Metropolitan Police directed the House committee's 1978 study of the backyard pictures. Leslie Stroebel, Andrew Davidhazy, and Ronald Francis, three Rochester Institute of Technology (RIT) scientists, answered 22 technical questions from the panel. The panel worked only from the original negative and first-generation prints, including four the committee had gathered since 1976, among them a third pose, 133-C, that the Warren Commission never saw.

Kirk's lab made a test exposure with Oswald's camera from the roof of police headquarters in Washington on August 1, 1978, and deliberately underexposed it so the frame edges would show. Each time film ran through the camera, the same irregular border and scratches appeared in the same places. To learn whether that signature was unique, RIT obtained two other Imperial Reflex Duo Lens cameras belonging to the International Museum of Photography at George Eastman House in Rochester, New York.

All three cameras had injection-molded plastic bodies with three circular indentations along each side of the aperture, and the shape of those distortions differed on each one. Oswald's also left two small projections near the bottom of the frame that neither museum camera produced. On the 133-B negative, the panel counted 11 distinct frame edge marks, each matching the test negatives. The same marks ran along the black border of a first-generation print of 133-A recovered from George de Mohrenschildt, though spotting all of them there took a light box and a magnifier.

On 8-by-8-inch prints from the backyard negative and from a negative RIT exposed in Oswald's camera, four prominent scratches also sat at the same spots, 36, 45, 52, and 112 mm in from the image's left side. "The identifiers are there, all of them, and in my opinion the same camera that produced the test photograph this year produced the 133-B backyard photograph," Kirk told the committee at a public hearing on September 14, 1978.

Oswald's Imperial Reflex, Commission Exhibit 750, photographed by the National Archives with its back removed beside an identification card. The House committee's photographic panel ran its 1978 tests on this camera. Photo by the National Archives, public domain. Source.

Shadows, Stereo Pairs, and a Line Across the Chin

The panel printed 133-A and 133-B at exposures from very light to very dark and examined the negative under microscopes. It also had the negative scanned in squares smaller than its silver grains, each graded on a 1,024-level density scale, so a computer could hunt for unnatural edges. Neither the panel nor RIT found a seam or a break in the grain between Oswald's head and body. One enhancement method at the Aerospace Corp. did show very fine, broken lines in the chin area, but it produced similar lines on a known authentic negative, and the panel judged them most likely an artifact of the process.

Critics had said the ground shadows were painted on, but the lighter prints showed grass, a small branch, what look like stones, and a newspaper inside them, illuminated by light reflected off the pale fence and wall. To test the shadows' directions, the panel used the vanishing-point principle. Sunlight makes the lines from objects to their shadows parallel, so those lines converge on one point in a photograph. Lines drawn from part of the stairway, the pistol's butt, the rifle's muzzle, and Oswald's nose to their shadows all met there.

The camera also moved between exposures, which made 133-A and 133-B a stereo pair. In a stereo viewer, the post stands in front of the fence, and leaves on the bush stand off the wall that carries their shadows. A rephotographed flat print would show no depth, and a pasted or retouched element would float in front of or behind its proper plane. Parallax measurements showed that the camera had shifted slightly left and down between 133-B and 133-A.

Known photographs show that Oswald had a natural line across his chin, and a Dallas police profile photograph shows a rounded protrusion on the lower half of the chin that, in sun from nearly overhead, would cast a shadow with a nearly straight upper edge. The hard line in later-generation copies came from the added contrast of copying. A faint ring on one enlargement of 133-A, running from Oswald's left ear into the chin, turned out to be the edge of a dried water spot on the original negative.

Oswald smiles in 133-A and appears to frown in 133-B, and overlays by the committee's contractors showed his head differing in shape and size between frames. Three horizontal shadows, possibly from power lines, cross a post in the foreground and sit higher on it in each frame as the afternoon sun drops, which put the poses in order: 133-C, then 133-B, then 133-A. The framing improves across that sequence, which the panel read as a photographer learning to center the subject.

Fitting a +4 diopter close-up lens to Oswald's camera, the RIT scientists copied a print and got a negative carrying the camera's edge marks and scratches. The copy also showed strong pincushion distortion, and a copied flat print lacks the slight stretching that real, three-dimensional heads take on away from the lens axis, which the backyard heads show. RIT wrote that the method raised many technical problems, each of which would expose a fake under close examination if left unsolved, and that it did not believe the backyard pictures were made that way.

"The panel detects no evidence of fakery in any of the backyard picture materials," the panel's report concludes. The panel also matched a wear mark on the rifle in the pictures to the rifle found in the Texas School Book Depository, an identification Shaneyfelt could not make in 1964. Malcolm Thompson, a British specialist in forensic photography who had called the pictures fakes in a 1978 BBC documentary, read a summary of the findings and deferred to them, noting that he had worked from copies, though he still found the chin suspicious. A Canadian defense department analyst who had called them composites told the committee he had run no scientific tests and spent less than an hour on "very poor copies."

Robert Groden, a photographic consultant to the committee and a critic of the Warren Commission, filed a dissent that the committee printed in the same volume. "In my opinion no matter what the panel members concluded, the backyard photographs are beyond question fakes," he wrote. His theory was that someone had posed a man in the backyard and added Oswald's head from mid-chin up.

The Print Oswald Signed for George de Mohrenschildt

On December 30, 1976, Geneva Dees of Paris, Texas, gave the committee a first-generation print of 133-C, which she said her former husband, Roscoe White, had acquired while employed by the Dallas police. R. L. Studebaker, who worked in the Dallas police photography lab in 1963, testified that he had made numerous copies of the photographic evidence for fellow officers, including the third pose.

George de Mohrenschildt, a Russian-born oil geologist who had befriended the Oswalds, died in an apparent suicide on March 29, 1977, the day a committee investigator and a writer contacted him. On April 1, his widow, Jeanne, gave the committee a print of 133-A and the manuscript of his unfinished book, described in a committee staff report. He wrote that the couple had found the picture in February 1967 among belongings they had stored before leaving for Haiti in May 1963. "It was a gift for us from beyond his grave," he wrote.

On the back, in blue ballpoint, is the inscription "To my friend George from Lee Oswald 5/IV/63," the day and then the month in Roman numerals, or April 5, 1963. A copyright notation and a Russian line calling Oswald a hunter of fascists, followed by laughter, share the back. The committee's handwriting panel attributed the English inscription and signature to Oswald but could not say whether he, Marina, or de Mohrenschildt wrote the rest. The photographic panel noted that the print's uncropped black border came from an oversized negative carrier, equipment a graphic arts or photo printing shop might have.

The newspapers could not have reached Oswald before about March 27, and by April 5 he had autographed a print to a friend, so a forger would have needed his backyard, camera, rifle, and the right newspapers within about 10 days. The panel called that theoretically possible but unlikely, and it noted that both Warren Commission prints carry a photofinishing machine's graphite mark on the back. The print from de Mohrenschildt's boxes shows the pose Fritz put in front of Oswald on November 23, the picture Oswald said he had never seen before, and it carries his signature.

Lead image by the President's Commission on the Assassination of President Kennedy, public domain. Source.

Read Entire Article