Jared Padalecki Is Right Where He Never Expected to Be

2 hours ago 33
Jared Padalecki poses for an exclusive Collider photo shoot at Netflix’s offices in Los Angeles on Wednesday, November 11, 2026. (Photo by Anthony Avellano for Collider) Photography by Anthony Avellano for Collider

With ‘Guarding Stars,’ Jared Padalecki is back to making audiences swoon — though he’d be just as happy making them laugh or discussing cookies.

Published Nov 18, 2026, 12:00 PM EST

Tania Hussain is an Executive Editor at Collider responsible for creative, editorial, and managerial duties. In addition to leading content ideation and development, she works to generate innovative and compelling ideas for feature articles and reviews with her editorial team across Features, Lists, Reviews, and Interviews. She also serves as the primary editor overseeing Collider’s Signature Series profiles, spotlighting some of the most influential voices in film and television. Tania has helped cover and ideate content for major events for Collider, including the Toronto International Film Festival. She has also conducted more than 100 interviews since her start in the business more than 15 years ago. Some favorites include Joel McHale, Charlie Cox, Jennifer Garner, Tina Fey, Kate Winslet, Bob Odenkirk, Andy Richter, Jordan Schlansky, Jamie Dornan, Yeardley Smith, Rafe Spall, Esther Smith, and a reasonable toss-up between Cookie Monster and Kermit the Frog. She has covered set visits, in-person junkets, and red carpets for several films and TV shows, including most recently, The Sheep Detectives, Masterchef, and Star Trek: Starfleet Academy.

Jared Padalecki has barely finished being photographed as your next holiday crush when he’s asked how he feels about the assignment. The Collider team, with help from photographer Anthony Avellano, has put him through the wringer with a festive shoot for his new Netflix rom-com, Guarding Stars. Based on Katherine Center’s best-selling novel The Bodyguard, the film has him playing a movie star the whole world is swooning over — something he might know a little about.

Between his years as Rory Gilmore’s first boyfriend Dean on Gilmore Girls and Sam Winchester on Supernatural, Padalecki has given audiences plenty of reasons to fall for him. This time, however, being everyone’s crush is just part of the job description. So, just how comfortable is he with that? “Oh my God, that’s a great question,” he laughs. “I guess I haven’t really allowed myself to think about it.”

At Netflix’s Los Angeles offices on an unreasonably warm and sunny November afternoon, the Texas native looks ready to play the part. He’s wearing a brown quarter-zip over a dark collared shirt; his hair is brushed back with a few curls at the ends. Then he smiles, and there’s that boyish face that makes it easy to remember why Rory fell for the new kid in town. Padalecki is good company, too. Over the course of our conversation, we get into his early days in L.A. and a surprisingly involved story about cookies with the sort of details you hope an actor will share when you have more time together than just a five-minute press slot.

But him being mysterious was once part of the persona. “I think back in the day, for me at least, maybe not everybody was this vapid, but I was more concerned about the look of it. Like, ‘This is the way romantic boys brood.’ It was very much the early 2000s. Everything was like the brooding guy who’s in a corner, and like, ‘Just don’t talk to me. I’m just so pensive,’ and I kind of fell prey to that.”

Jared Padalecki poses for an exclusive Collider photo shoot at Netflix’s offices in Los Angeles on Wednesday, November 11, 2026. (Photo by Anthony Avellano for Collider) Photography by Anthony Avellano for Collider

Padalecki admits his agents sometimes had to remind him what they were going for. “Because I’m a pretty happy-go-lucky guy, they’d be like, ‘Hey, just tone it down a little bit and be mysterious.’ And I’m like, ‘Okay, okay. I need to eat, so I’d like to book this role.’”

Now he’s playing Jack Stapleton, a movie star who falls for his bodyguard, Hannah Brooks, played by Gossip Girl alum Leighton Meester. But while Guarding Stars might bring him back to romance after years spent hunting monsters on Supernatural and chasing criminals on Walker, he admits it took more practice than he expected. “To try and refresh that muscle, so to speak, was actually more difficult than I thought it would be,” he says.

When asked about his romantic leading man inspiration for Jack, Padalecki brings up George Clooney, Brad Pitt, Matthew McConaughey, and Hugh Grant, saying what appeals to him the most about these rom-com leads is their humor.

“You want to be around people who laugh a lot, even in a shitty situation. You’re delayed on a flight on the tarmac for four hours, and someone’s like, ‘Well, at least it’s not five hours,’ and you’re like, ‘That’s a better perspective,’” he says. “That frequency is really inviting to people. That’s what I lean towards in my real life: people who want to laugh and tease and play and joke and have fun.”

It's not hard picturing him being that person.

Jared Padalecki Is Giving Himself Room To Play in ‘Guarding Stars’

Meester’s Hannah, though, takes a little more convincing. Watching Jack trying to win her over in Netflix’s latest festive treat, I’m reminded of the back-and-forth banter between Cary Grant and Rosalind Russell in His Girl Friday. Hannah is a tough audience, and the fun is in watching Padalecki’s Jack figure her out. And Padalecki gives his co-star the credit for this dynamic. “She has a ridiculously awesome sense of humor. She’s obviously a very talented actress, and she can do it all,” he smiles.

Lucky for the audience, the seasoned actors knew a scene could survive a few experimental takes. “Because she and I have both been in this industry for 20-plus years and worked with hundreds or thousands of people, I felt like, ‘Yeah, we’re gonna play. Alright. Let’s figure it out.’ And then we’d do a take and didn’t really love it, and like, ‘Let’s do it again.’”

He compares the dynamic with Meester to playing tennis with someone who can keep up, although his explanation comes with a small disclaimer: “Not that I’m saying I’m a great tennis player, but you kind of know, ‘Okay, cool. Let’s try this. I’m going to try a spike. I’m gonna try a backhand. I’m going to try to curve it,’ or whatever. I don’t know the tennis terms.”

Padalecki makes it clear that having someone willing to try things out with him makes it easier to take a chance. Director Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum and writer-producer Gina Matthews encouraged that approach throughout filming, giving the actors space to wander as long as they landed where the story needed them. “There was some stuff in the rodeo that wasn’t necessarily scripted,” he says. “To Liz’s credit, and Gina, who was on set as well, they let us kind of, like, ‘Here’s the direction. Here are the key points in the scene that we need to do.’”

Padalecki reveals the film’s rodeo scene alone took two days to shoot. Between the cast, background performers, and stunt teams, there was plenty to coordinate, giving the actor and his scene partners time to settle into those bleachers. “There was just a lot to get, and so we were kind of sitting there, and we were just kind of vibing with it.”

Revisiting romantic comedies also helped him to worry less about looking the part. “It wasn’t just Fabio on a romance book cover with the big pecs and the long, flowing hair, and the eight-pack and stuff like that — not that I have any of those. But it wasn’t about, like, ‘I need to make sure I look a certain way.’”

Guarding Stars not only has Padalecki returning to the rom-com genre following the severely underrated hidden gem New York Minute, but it also brings him back to Christmas movies. Eighteen years after playing a young Thomas Kinkade in Christmas Cottage, Padalecki knows the appeal of a fun and compelling Christmas rewatch. With the romance and two exciting leads who are equally exciting to watch, Guarding Stars similarly offers the sort of company you could happily revisit every December.

“I’m like a kid who just wanted to go outside and play pretend. I happened to get to do it in front of cameras.”

The family side of Jack’s life was familiar territory, too. Padalecki’s wife and fellow executive producer, Genevieve Padalecki, read Center’s novel first, more than four years ago. She could see him in the character, having watched him work a convention crowd and then come home to a considerably less glamorous set of responsibilities. “She sees me waking up at 5:00 a.m. to help the kids get ready for school, taking the dog out and picking up dog poop, and dragging the garbage cans to the street, and going to my kids’ games and plays and stuff like that.”

Genevieve could see both sides of Jack in her husband. “I think she saw the version of Jared that’s kind of like the Jack Stapleton we meet at first and also what is beneath those coats of armor that Jack Stapleton put on himself to be in the industry that he’s in — which I guess is kind of the industry I’m in, as well.”

Working with Meester also meant working with someone who understood his life outside the film. “She and her husband [Adam Brody] and me and my wife went out to dinner with their kids, and it was very like, ‘Okay, we know we’re doing a job. We’re going to be kissing on camera…’ Maybe. Maybe not. Spoiler alert. But it was very comfortable,” he explains. “The four of us are all actors, and so we get it. I sat across from her husband, and she’s sitting across from my wife… it was like, ‘Okay, cool. We all feel safe. We all know this is our job. We’re going to do our best and try to serve the characters.’”

For his part, Padalecki found a way into Jack through a much younger version of himself. “I think I’m still 8 years old half the time,” he laughs. “I’m like a kid who just wanted to go outside and play pretend. I happened to get to do it in front of cameras, and I get paid to do it, which is wild, and I’m grateful.”

Padalecki Didn’t Know This Would Be His Life

Jared Padalecki poses for an exclusive Collider photo shoot at Netflix’s offices in Los Angeles on Wednesday, November 11, 2026. (Photo by Anthony Avellano for Collider) Photography by Anthony Avellano for Collider

That gratitude can be traced back to his Texas roots and school plays that started in the sixth grade, even if it meant missing out on what everyone else was doing. Sports were a big part of his life, too, though he remembers looking around at the other boys and reconsidering his options. “I’m a large person now, but I was small by Texas standards as a freshman, so I think I was like 5’8”, 115 pounds, and there are freshmen that are like 6’2”, 180 already. So I was kind of undersized for basketball and football, and I was like, ‘Well, I guess I’ll get more into drama.’”

He liked the drama program, even if it didn’t make him popular. “Our drama program was great, and a lot of great actors and actresses were there with us, but it wasn’t the cool thing to do,” he remembers, recalling a time when he had to pick between theater and doing the cool thing. “I couldn’t go to homecoming when I was a junior because we had rehearsal for a play that was two weeks later. So I wasn’t really in the ‘cool kid group,’ so to speak. I didn’t not get along with anybody — double negative intended — but I didn’t really know a lot of people.”

Later, when Padalecki first drove from his hometown of San Antonio to L.A., he had thoughts of returning to the University of Texas for school. Acting was something he could try for a while, but the idea was to save enough money to help cover college. “My intention was to do as much as I could, stock away the money, and then go pay off student loans at UT. I always thought I was going to go back to college until probably Season 3 or 4 of Gilmore Girls, when I was like, ‘You know what? I think this might be a career option.’”

At first, he says, the show offered him just four episodes. But then the calls kept coming. “‘We kind of like their chemistry. Can you come back for three more?’ ‘Sure.’ ‘We kind of like him. Can you come back for four more?’ ‘Sure.’ ‘We’re liking him more now. Can you come back for the rest of the season?’ ‘Yeah. Of course.’”

He turned 18 while filming his scenes for the Gilmore Girls pilot in L.A., where nobody on set knew it was his birthday. After a long day of shoots, he’d go home to the studio apartment he was subletting, where even closing the door was a problem. “The door didn’t close, so I had this, like, wedge from Hammacher Schlemmer that you put batteries in, and if someone opens the door, it connects, and beep!” he laughs.

“I always thought I was going to go back to college until probably Season 3 or 4 of ‘Gilmore Girls.’”

He remembers his Magnavox television set, a DVD player, a VCR player, and his Scooby-Doo and James Bond tapes. Life wasn’t easy, as the 44-year-old admits that money was tight. His biggest bill at the time was his gym membership at Bally Total Fitness. “I was living off ramen and stuff,” he says. “They’d always make fun of me because I’d go to set, and if I wasn’t in the last scene of the day, I would still stick around and stay in my trailer, and then when they called wrap, I’d go to craft services, and if they had food they were going to throw away, I’d take it home.”

Which brings us to the cookies. There is an unfiltered joy in how Padalecki recalls a memory of a place called the Hollywood Cookie Company on Burbank Boulevard (sadly now closed). “They [had] these giant cookies, and there’d be like, 30 left at the end of the day, so I’d ask if I could take them,” he says. “I’d put bags of chips in my backpack and granola bars, and that’s kind of how I survived for several months.”

But after reading about calories in Men’s Health, despite admitting he was a “string bean” at the time, he decided to call the store with a question. “‘Hey, how many calories do your cookies have?’ And the guy was like, ‘Uhh, do you enjoy them?’ I was like, ‘Yeah, I love them.’ He’s like, ‘Well, as much as you love them is how many calories they have.’ I was like, ‘Got it,’” he laughs. “I think they’re like 5,000 calories per cookie or something, but I would plow through them like no man’s business.”

At work, he had someone else figuring things out alongside him. Alexis Bledel was also from Texas and new to L.A. as well. “We were both like fish out of water,” he says, adding that Milo Ventimiglia also helped him learn his way around, including the fairly important discovery that he could leave work for lunch.

“We were shooting a scene, and we broke for lunch, and he was like, ‘Hey, there’s a vegan restaurant down the street. You want to come with?’ And I was like, ‘We can leave?’ He’s like, ‘Yeah. What do you mean?’ I was like, ‘Well, we don’t have to go to our trailers?’ He’s like, ‘No, just give the [assistant director] your phone number, and they’ll call you and tell you when it’s like 20 minutes until you’re on set.’ And so we would go to lunch, and he would help me out figuring out how to navigate certain things.”

Padalecki Has a Different View of ‘Gilmore Girls’ Dean Forester

Jared Padalecki poses for an exclusive Collider photo shoot at Netflix’s offices in Los Angeles on Wednesday, November 11, 2026. (Photo by Anthony Avellano for Collider) Photography by Anthony Avellano for Collider

That fondness and friendship with Ventimiglia might also explain his answer to a question everyone at Collider insisted we ask: Team Dean, Team Jess, or Team Logan. Padalecki answers without any hesitation: “I’m Team Jess, and I kind of always have been even while shooting it.”

Somewhere in the world, a Team Dean fan needs a minute. But Padalecki is happy to give Rory’s second boyfriend his due. “I love Milo, and I did really appreciate Jess and Rory’s arc, [but] as far as indefensible, I’m not a huge fan of the idea of [Dean] sleeping with Rory when you’re married. I don’t think that was ideal. He had his moments.”

He also has a theory about why Dean became harder to root for as the show went on. Having since worked as a producer on several projects, including Guarding Stars, Padalecki now thinks about the practical problems of keeping a character around when the actor playing him might be leaving. “I think part of the reason why Dean kind of veered off was because [I] wasn’t on a multi-year contract. So if the audience and Rory fell head-over-heels in love with Dean, and then I got Supernatural, all of a sudden, Dean’s not around anymore; he’s in Vancouver. He’s named Sam now.”

He’s clear that this is just his guess and admits he hasn’t discussed it with Gilmore Girls creator Amy Sherman-Palladino. But looking back at how much he was working elsewhere, he can see why the writers might have needed some room to move around. “Even Season 5 of Gilmore Girls, I did Flight of the Phoenix and Cry Wolf and House of Wax, and so I wasn’t there. I wasn’t in L.A. to do it at all. So I think they had to cover their asses, so to speak, and go, like, ‘Let’s make him questionable.’”

Padalecki also has a kinder picture of where Dean might be now despite everything. Dean’s brief return in Netflix’s Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life gave him a family and a life beyond Rory, which Padalecki attributes simply to the fact that getting older helped him make sense of his younger self. “He’s grown. He realizes that he was a kid and he made mistakes, and I think he’d be happy to see everybody and have that small-town lifestyle. I mean, who wouldn’t want to live in Stars Hollow, you know?”

For all the love Padalecki holds for the series, he also shares that his daughter Odette has finally seen some of it, but she has a complaint of her own. “She doesn’t like when Dad kisses other people that aren’t Mom. I’m not kidding,” he laughs. “She’s like, ‘Why is he kissing that girl?’ Whether it’s Supernatural or Walker or Gilmore Girls.”

Padalecki Learned How To Show Up Thanks to ‘Supernatural’

 Jack Rowand / © The CW / Courtesy Everett Collection Image via Warner Bros., The CW; Everett Collection

Years after arriving in L.A. and finding a fellow Texan in Bledel, Padalecki met someone else who reminded him of home. He and Jensen Ackles had a few things in common before they ever climbed into the Impala for one of TV’s best shows of all time, Supernatural. “His parents still lived in the same house he grew up in, like mine. Older brother, younger sister, like me. He watched the Cowboys. I end up finding other Texans,” he smiles.

The two would spend the next 15 years playing brothers. As Sam and Dean Winchester, Padalecki and Ackles made a life out of saving people, hunting things, and occasionally making a mess of their own lives. Through it all, the brothers kept coming back to each other. As Ackles learned when we spoke last year, that bond made the show more than appointment viewing in my own household. When I share that same story with Padalecki, the actor is evidently touched and humbly responds to it.

Having spent so long watching Sam care for other people and often putting them before himself, Padalecki admits he’s learned a lot from playing the younger Winchester and what it means to show up for others in times of need. “I learned so much from Sam, from Supernatural, and showing up,” he says. “I think this is a different route to showing up, [but] Sam and Dean did a lot of great things; they also made a lot of mistakes, but they forgave each other for their mistakes. They didn’t forget them.”

He knows the brothers could be a little more direct when somebody needed help, too. “It’s not just like, ‘Someone’s picking on you? I’ll fucking kill ’em,’ you know? ‘Come at me, bro!’ It’s more like, ‘Hey, that was really jacked up what you did with that demon or how you left me and Dad [Jeffrey Dean Morgan], or whatever, but I get it. I get that you’re a human and you make mistakes.’”

While the demons are a fairly specific problem, the rest is something he can use in his real life. “To offer the grace that you hope to get, which is, I think, the best way I’ve found of showing up at this point in my life,” he says. Padalecki admits that caring for someone can also mean accepting that you can’t always get in the car and come over. The dad of three with a marriage of more than 15 years wants his friends to know he’s available, even when he can’t be there in person.

“I do feel confident that I gave everything I had to every character I’ve ever played.”

“I’m older, I’m married, I have kids. I’m really busy. I can’t necessarily drive over to my buddy’s house if his dog dies — knock on wood — as a for instance, but I can offer them the forgiveness and emotional availability.” His wife, Genevieve, helped him understand that being useful doesn’t always require having an answer too. “I learned this from Gen during Supernatural: sometimes showing up doesn’t mean doing anything; it means just listening.”

To explain, he acts out the sort of conversation that can quickly turn a bad day into an opportunity to vent and feel better. Someone tells you they were cut off in traffic, and suddenly you’re asking what the other driver looked like, where they were going, and whether anyone got a license plate. “Like, ‘No, no, I don’t want you to do anything. I just want to let you know. I just want to vent or invite you to my day, but you don’t have to do anything. Just let me tell you about it.’”

Padalecki can see that same patience in Sam, too. Beneath the fake badges and whatever story the Winchesters had invented to get through someone’s front door, Sam was often the one checking on the person left behind. “We’d go interview somebody who had lost a loved one. We’re doing our fake FBI this or our fake cop that, fake medical exam, and Sam was always the one who was just listening. Then Dean’s like, ‘Alright, let’s go get them,’ and Sam’s like, ‘Wait, wait. How are you feeling?’ Like, ‘You gonna be okay?’”

He admits those small exchanges stayed with him — as did the idea that a phone call could be enough, provided the person on the other end knew he would listen. “‘Hey, I’m here. If I don’t have my phone, leave a message. When I get my phone, I’ll listen to the message, and I’ll text you back or call you back. But I know you’re not asking me to, like, fly to you right now and beat up your neighbor who keyed your car or something. But I’ll listen to you talk about it.’”

When I tell him that care comes through the screen, especially in how he constructs his latest character in Guarding Stars, he explains that’s how he knows he’s done his job. “I do feel confident that I gave everything I had to every character I’ve ever played.”

While he’d welcome a billion viewers, as that would help him get another role, he also thinks about the person who comes up to tell him a performance genuinely meant something to them. “If one person is like, ‘Hey, that meant a lot,’ that means a lot to me, and I can at least go to bed knowing at the end of the day that I gave it everything I could, not just on the day, but in preparation and practicing the lines and thinking about the storyline, and this and that. So, I can rest on that.”

Padalecki Wants To Make Room for Life Outside Work

Jared Padalecki poses for an exclusive Collider photo shoot at Netflix’s offices in Los Angeles on Wednesday, November 11, 2026. (Photo by Anthony Avellano for Collider) Photography by Anthony Avellano for Collider

By the time Padalecki landed the titular role in Walker in 2021, he had already spent years watching how a set could run behind the scenes. On Supernatural, there were some directors who returned often and others who were just joining them for the first time. But with every interaction, Padalecki paid close attention to how each person worked and what happened when a day got difficult. “We got to see a bunch of different leadership styles and what worked and what didn’t,” he says before pausing. “Like yelling on a set doesn’t make it faster; it works the opposite.”

As both the lead and an EP on Walker, he could help decide how things would work, and the rule was simple, as he puts it, “We had a thing on Walker: Life first.”

Padalecki shares how that applied to everyone he worked with, ensuring it was a familial, understanding environment. If a crew member’s daughter had a play, they could leave to see it. If someone needed to visit a sick relative, the conversation was always about how to cover their work. Sharing stories about those he’s worked with on set, it’s evident he puts a lot of care and consideration into how these spaces need to function for individual needs. And he’s proud of the reputation the set earned in Austin, one that quickly earned them a reputation.

“All of the other crews in Austin would call it Disneyland,” he laughs. “So they’d call our key hair or key makeup, our camera operator, like, ‘How’s it over in Disneyland?’ Because they would be doing a different show that was shooting all night and people are yelling at everybody, and they’re underpaid and overworked.”

He gives Ackles and the Supernatural cast and crew credit for helping him learn how to build that kind of workplace effectively. But as he puts it, leaving Sam behind took some time. The pandemic stopped production near the end of the final season, giving Padalecki an unexpected stretch to prepare for Cordell Walker before returning to finish the Winchesters’ story. “It seems like it was really quick, I suppose, but really, I had five months to say bye to Sam. I knew I was going to go back and shoot for three weeks or whatever to finish the series, but I was able to start building a relationship with Walker, starting to understand him.”

“We had a thing on ‘Walker’: Life first.”

But for those wondering, Sam Winchester is still close by, should anyone need him. “Roll a camera and give me a scene, and I can bust into Sam in an instant,” he says with a chuckle, though finding the time to do it is another question. When talk turns to a possible Supernatural return for Season 16, Padalecki has a clear idea of the commitment he could make now. His children are growing up, and the schedule that once worked would mean missing too much.

“I don’t think any of us want to do Supernatural like we did Seasons 1 through 15. We’re each at different points in our lives. We all have kids or are married. So, nine months out of the year is a lot to dedicate when you have a kid who’s about to get a driver’s license and a kid who’s about to be a teenager,” he says.

But his preferred version borrows from another familiar show. “Ideally for me, it would look something like the Gilmore Girls reboot, like four 90-minute episodes. We’ll shoot it in two months or three months.” And as for the story? Padalecki has an idea in mind, rather than an announced plan: Sam and Dean find themselves back on Earth, with no explanation for how they got there.

“They’ve got work to do. They don’t know exactly what yet. They don’t know why they’re even there, but they have to sleuth it out,” he pitches. There is, however, one option he can rule out: “The one thing we cannot do is a prequel because we look a lot older than we did 25 years ago, or 21 years ago,” he laughs.

For now, he’s working on something new with people he knows very well. A Fire Country spin-off remains a possibility, he says, as his friendship with co-creator and EP Max Thieriot goes back more than a decade. But the project he’s focused on developing is with Walker’s Anna Fricke, Genevieve, and others from their circle. “Right now, Anna and Gen and I, and a few of our gang, are developing a show that we hope will go,” he says of the previously announced medical drama for CBS.

He’s hopeful it’ll come through, though he’s been doing this long enough to know that wanting a show to happen and getting it made are two different things. “It’s moving forward. We’re still in the process of developing it. It’s just that everything takes a little bit longer these days than it used to. If it was 2000, we’d have an answer by now. But it’s just the way it goes.”

Padalecki Still Finds the Goodbyes Hard

Jared Padalecki poses for an exclusive Collider photo shoot at Netflix’s offices in Los Angeles on Wednesday, November 11, 2026. (Photo by Anthony Avellano for Collider) Photography by Anthony Avellano for Collider

It makes sense that Padalecki is hoping for another series — frankly, we all are. The actor likes spending time with a character, enough to watch them make some mistakes and see what their next move is. When asked what matters to him when choosing a project, like Gilmore Girls, Supernatural, or Walker, Padalecki happily leads with his heart.

“What I found, in hindsight, that I really loved about all three of those projects is that my character kept growing and growing and growing and growing and growing,” he says. “Even if you grew sideways or grew backwards for a second, then you pick yourself up, or the character does, and you keep going.”

While he had fun making Guarding Stars, he wishes the part where everyone goes home didn’t come quite so soon. “Guarding Stars was essentially four months,” he says of the Calgary shoot. “It’s like going to camp and meeting people and having a great time, as opposed to going to school with them for all your high school years and sitting at the table next to them so your relationship grows and you have ups and downs and lefts and rights.”

On a series, Padalecki mentions how there’s the hope of getting everyone back together after a few months off. So, finishing this film meant saying goodbye to something he and Genevieve had been working on for years. “It felt like a hard goodbye,” he says. “We’re friends with Katherine, the author, and friends now with the cast and the crew, with the writers, the fellow producers, and the director.”

But he’s still getting used to having to finish it. “It’s weird to rip that Band-Aid off before you think you’ve given it a chance to heal. Like, ‘What do we do now? What are we going to do?’”

There are parts of Jack’s life he’s happier to leave on set, though. Playing someone that famous meant imagining what it would be like to lose the freedom he still enjoys. “I don’t envy Brad Pitt and George Clooney, and Justin Timberlake in music. They can’t go anywhere. I still have a relative degree of anonymity where I can often go out, go for a walk, put some sunglasses on, my headphones in.”

“I still have a difficult time watching my work with anybody who doesn’t have a last name Padalecki.”

He gets recognized, of course. But the encounters he describes are usually brief and always friendly. “Maybe someone taps me on the shoulder, and they’re like, ‘Hey, I like Gilmore Girls or Supernatural or Walker,’ and it’s a very kind interaction. It’s not like I’m being chased down the street and trying to run into a building to hide.”

To understand Jack, he drew on people he’s met over his career. Of course, there were plenty to choose from. “I’ve certainly met very famous people, and some people that aren’t that famous but think they are,” he says. “So I was trying to do an amalgamation of all my experiences.”

Naturally, his own plans for the spotlight are fairly modest. When we speak, the L.A. premiere for Guarding Stars is the following day, and Padalecki already knows when he’ll be leaving his seat before the movie starts. “I’m going to be there at the screening, and I’m going to do the red carpet, and I think we’re going to introduce the movie, and when the lights in the theater dim, I’m going to the lobby, because I still don’t like watching myself,” he says with a slight laugh.

Working on the film as an EP gives him something practical to focus on. “As a producer, making sure the nuts and bolts all work, I get it. I can kind of detach myself and go, like, ‘Oh, that take is too long. We need to cut 30 seconds from the scene,’ or ‘We need to flesh this out and add more reaction shots.’”

But once those decisions are made, sitting down to watch himself is another matter — and that feeling goes back much further than Guarding Stars. “I still haven’t seen Supernatural. I’ve seen a lot of it, but I still have a difficult time watching my work with anybody who doesn’t have a last name Padalecki,” he laughs, admitting he’s “very hypercritical” of himself. “I’ll watch it with my kids or some buddies here and there, but, yeah, I get really anxious, and I’m like, ‘My work here is done.’”

A Christmas romance does seem better suited to a couch, a blanket, and people who won’t mind if you talk through your own scenes. But as he shares, there will be another chance this holiday. Ahead of Thanksgiving, Genevieve is having friends and family over to watch the movie, which Padalecki admits he’ll join in on. “But I’ll sneak out here and there to go walk the dog or something.”

After all the work of bringing Jack Stapleton to the screen, Padalecki might miss a little of his own holiday romance. His dog, however, is in for an excellent evening.

Photographer: Anthony Avellano | Assistants: Christian Scutt, Caroline Brodt, Clodagh Ryan | Location: Netflix Offices, Los Angeles | Groomer: Kerrie Urban | Stylist: Ariana Weisner | Digi Tech: DJ Dohar

wwnizz4icsld3xxh1wexzijinjn.jpg
Guarding Stars

Release Date November 18, 2026

Director Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum

Writers Richard Keith, Erin Cardillo

Producers Genevieve Padalecki, Gina Matthews, Jared Padalecki, Grant Scharbo
Read Entire Article