Published Nov 22, 2026, 5:00 AM EST
Nicholas Becher is a gaming journalist with an MFA in Creative Writing from FAU. With extensive experience playing video games, he covers all forms of gaming content at Screen Rant, from breaking news to the latest fan theories. Most-played games range from Clair Obscur to Civ to Elden Ring to Halo 2 and beyond.
Dungeon Crawler Carl is arguably one of the most successful modern science fantasy IPs in recent memory, with author Matt Dinniman's universe growing to eight massive novels since its humble beginnings as a self-published project on Royal Road. Dinniman has always had a relatively unique and unconventional approach to storytelling, but one that has captivated readers more and more with each new installment.
Dungeon Crawler Carl's world-building, character backstories, and unexpected array of enemies, allies, and aliens are just the beginning of what makes the story so special. One of the most interesting aspects of how the story has evolved over its lifetime is that many of the most unique and outlandish details aren't even created by Dinniman alone. The author actually breaks a longstanding "unwritten rule" among fantasy/sci-fi writers, and it's safe to say that the creative choice has paid off time and time again.
Dungeon Crawler Carl's Fans Have Completely Reshaped The Story
One of the most fascinating aspects of Dungeon Crawler Carl is that Matt Dinniman has actually allowed his readers to influence the direction of the story, sometimes in pretty significant ways. Through his Patreon, Dinniman gives subscribers early access to upcoming chapters, but he also regularly invites them to vote on certain elements that will eventually appear in the books.
These aren't just simple polls about favorite characters or potential storylines, and Dinniman gives readers different possibilities for everything from enemies and rewards to locations, names, and other unexpected details. Some of these decisions are relatively minor, while others have ended up playing important roles in the larger narrative. In many cases, the results have even caught Dinniman himself off guard.
Importantly, this doesn't mean readers are deciding what Carl does or what Donut says. Dinniman maintains creative control over his characters and their decisions, instead allowing fans to influence the external circumstances they encounter. He then has to figure out how to incorporate those choices into the story, even when readers select something completely unexpected.
It's a fairly unconventional approach to writing a fantasy series, and one that breaks the "unwritten rule" that many fantasy authors follow of keeping the world-building elements of the story very intentional and deliberate. In many ways, Dinniman allows readers to throw him curveballs as some sort of a challenge to himself to make these things work on the page, and so far there are countless examples of how it's paid off.
Dinniman's Readers Introduced Iconic Details In Dungeon Crawler Carl
Credit: Dandy HouseThe extent of Dinniman's collaboration with fans is pretty remarkable, especially when looking at just how many important details have originated from reader polls. A recent Reddit post compiled some of the biggest decisions Patreon subscribers have influenced over the years, including several that could have dramatically changed the series.
Some of the most notable examples include:
- The Dungeon Anarchist's Cookbook: An early poll included the Cookbook as a potential reward. A reward room actually won, but Dinniman incorporated both ideas, letting Carl select the Cookbook himself.
- Orthrus: The enormous two-headed wolf was selected by readers, narrowly beating out a giant turkey and several other ridiculous creatures.
- Cuba: The Caribbean was selected as a destination through one poll, with Cuba subsequently winning another vote to determine the specific location.
- FUPA: The hilariously named Fortress of Unyielding Power and Authority won a poll to determine the Home Team's stronghold name.
- Samantha: Readers selected Samantha to narrate the recap of Book 7, with more than 10,000 votes cast across the available options.
- Satan's Water Park: This bizarre racing environment was another fan-selected addition to the eighth novel.
Beyond Patreon, Dinniman has also incorporated suggestions from fellow writers. Author Steve Rowland, the troll stripper in the Desperado Club, was named after real-life fantasy author S.L. Rowland, who jokingly suggested his own name when Dinniman requested stripper names on Twitter.
It's pretty incredible how many beloved elements of Dungeon Crawler Carl would have been completely different without fans contributing to the creative process, and it's a major piece of what makes the series so special.
Publisher(s) Penguin Random House
Publication Date September 21, 2020
Number of Pages 444
ISBN# 979-8688591507









English (US) ·