He’s an ambitious deckhand who fought his way up the yachting ranks to become a star of the reality show Below Deck but his new surroundings could hardly be further from the sun-drenched superyachts, boozy nights and crew romances of the Hayu series.
For earlier this month, Joao Franco was locked away in a Turkish prison after a fight that left a 17-year-old dead. Joao, 36, and his brother Karlos, 34, had been out drinking on the night of Saturday, November 7 when they got caught up in an argument with employees of a clothing shop in the Carsi neighbourhood of the Aegean port town of Bodrum.
What started the dispute is unclear but, according to local news reports, the brothers started swearing and the row escalated into a physical brawl outside the shop.
During the fight, teenage shop worker Muhammet Koyabakan fell and hit his head on the ground. He suffered a serious head injury and went into cardiac arrest before being taken to hospital where he died two days later.
Now, with the brothers having spent 11 days behind bars, Joao’s former colleagues from Below Deck insist to the Daily Mail that he is a ‘good person’.
In CCTV footage that has since emerged, Joao appears to step between Karlos and a group of employees outside the shop. Seconds later, as the confrontation erupts into a full-blown brawl, a punch is thrown and a man falls to the ground.
The brothers have denied hitting Koyabakan and told police they acted in self-defence. But the siblings remain in custody in Turkey, where prisons are notorious for their harsh conditions and being severely overcrowded.
And, the Daily Mail can today reveal, that Joao’s co-stars – including a former love interest and his old captain – have rallied to defend him. After watching the CCTV footage of the fight, they insist that he was acting in self-defence.
Joao Franco was locked up in a Turkish prison after a fight that left a 17-year-old dead
CCTV footage has since emerged, where Joao appears to step between Karlos and a group of employees outside the shop
‘Joao is a good person,’ says Captain Sandy Yawn, 61, who has starred on the show for around a decade and helped guide the reality star’s rise from deckhand to bosun (the most senior member of a crew).
‘I could only see what everyone else did,’ Captain Sandy adds. ‘It looked like he was trying to de-escalate the situation. I just pray for them all. It’s so sad for all involved.’
Ellie Dubaich, who had a romantic fallout with Joao while filming the latest series of Below Deck Down Under, also says she believes he was acting in self-defence.
‘This is such a tragedy on so many levels and I’ve been shaken up by it all,’ she says. ‘I don’t have anything bad to say about Joao and believe this was self-defence based on the video.’
Ellie’s decision to speak out is particularly striking because she and Joao haven’t always been on good terms. When the pair started working on season four of Below Deck Down Under earlier this year, Ellie admitted she was romantically interested in Joao, describing him as: ‘My type to a T’.
The pair kissed in Joao’s bunk and exchanged cheeky conversations over text. But their flirtations came to an abrupt end when Joao publicly told his colleague, Mike Durrant, that he preferred another crew member. Ellie said she felt ‘played’ and ‘stupid’ – and the fallout became one of the show’s main storylines.
Other crew members who have worked with Joao rushed to his defence, including Colin Macy-O’Toole, who told the New York Post’s Page Six gossip column: ‘Having seen the video footage, my impression is that Joao appeared to be trying to defend himself and de-escalate an already escalating situation.’
Barbie Pascual, who worked with Joao on Below Deck Down Under, also took to her Instagram story to say: ‘My heart is heavy over the tragic loss of the 17-year-old boy, and my prayers are with his family during this devastating time. I’m also praying for Joao, his brother, his girlfriend and his family as they live through this nightmare.’
She added: ‘Seeing him step in to protect his brother is completely consistent with the person I know.’
Joao, 36, and his brother Karlos, 34, remain in custody in Turkey (from Joao Franco's Instagram)
Some fans of the show may be surprised by the heartfelt statements coming from Joao’s co-stars, considering his time on screen hasn’t always made for comfortable viewing.
Joao first appeared on the series in 2018 as a lead deckhand under Captain Sandy and returned the following season as a bosun. But on nights out, his fellow yachties saw a different side to him.
He became rude, belittling and short-tempered after a few drinks and his nasty drunk alter ego was given the nickname ‘Jezabob’. While it was a joke at the time, Joao later admitted his drunken behaviour got him into ‘a lot of trouble’.
Speaking in 2019, he said: ‘I’d get absolutely obliterated and not remember anything and that was also to stop myself from getting emotional. If I got blind drunk I couldn’t feel any emotion. I’d get angry instead.’
During his first season, a wine glass shattered in Joao’s hand during a tense dinner involving crewmates Hannah Ferrier and Brooke Laughton. Joao insisted it was an accident but his former colleague Conrad Empson recalled events differently.
‘He was listening to [Hannah and Brooke’s conversation],’ Conrad said. ‘If you watch him slowly, he was watching it, ready to snap it [the glass].’
Just weeks before the incident in Turkey, Joao took to social media to say he wanted to ‘reassess [his] values’ and ‘realign [his] moral compass.’
‘Less ego. More humility. Less reaction. More understanding. Less judgment. More compassion,’ he wrote. ‘At the end of the day, I don’t want to be remembered only for what I’ve achieved, but for how I’ve treated people along the way.’
But with Joao still in custody following the fight, it remains to be seen whether his mission to change his ways came too late.
And his altercation is by no means the only serious controversy to involve a Below Deck star.
In 2023, Luke Jones, a bosun on Below Deck Down Under, was fired after entering the cabin of an intoxicated female crewmate while naked and attempting to get into her bed. Second steward Laura Bileskalne was also dismissed after repeatedly making unwanted advances towards fellow cast member Adam Kodra.
Then came allegations that Below Deck Sailing Yacht star Gary King attempted to rape a production worker. Samantha Suarez, who was working as a hair and make-up artist on the show in July 2022, is suing King for alleged sexual battery and for restraining her after filming – which he denies.
Last December, Below Deck Mediterranean cast member Nathan Gallagher was arrested in Sydney for assaulting his then-partner and co-star, Gael Cameron, while she was holding their baby boy. According to police reports, Gallagher was charged with assault occasioning actual bodily harm, choking without consent and common assault of Cameron.
Gallagher pleaded not guilty to all three charges but failed to appear in court in Australia on September 1. A warrant for his arrest was subsequently issued, and he was convicted of all charges in absentia.
Following the latest allegations, fans online are finding it harder to write off the show’s rows as nothing more than bad behaviour brought on by exhaustion coupled with too much booze.
As one longtime viewer put it: ‘I’ve watched Below Deck for years and it feels as though the show is always sailing from one scandal to the next. There is always another drunken row, another allegation or another police matter. But a 17-year-old dying is on another level entirely.’

6 hours ago
17








English (US) ·