AI is reshaping one creative industry after another, and I think music is next. I just used AI-generated music in a YouTube video for the very first time. I'm completely conflicted about it, but I feel like I was pushed into it by the copyright claims happening behind the scenes on YouTube, where people claim to own music you have every legal right to use, or that you literally paid for, and then collect your ad revenue anyway.
Fifteen Years of Paying for Music
I've been making YouTube videos for more than 15 years. In the beginning it was the Wild West, and nobody really knew what was legal, so everybody used popular copyrighted songs. Then YouTube built an automated system that listens for copyrighted music. If a video used a protected song, YouTube would ask the copyright holder whether they wanted the video pulled down or wanted to collect all of the ad revenue from it.
About 12 or 13 years ago, we decided it wasn't worth the risk. We stopped using popular music entirely and built a library of royalty-free tracks we bought outright, with the right to use them in any video. None of those songs were incredible, but they were good enough for YouTube, and I believe I've spent more than $10,000 building that library over the years.
The Claims Started Anyway
A few years ago, I made a video where I gave my dad a classic Camaro. It was the most expensive video I've ever made and also the most popular. As it gained views, I got a copyright claim from someone saying they owned one of the songs in it, a song I had bought from a royalty-free music site. I disputed it and explained that I'd purchased the track. The reply was one sentence: my dispute was rejected, and the claimant would get the revenue.
By then the video had something like a million views, and I had a choice. I could take down the best performing video we'd ever made, re-edit it with different music and hope that didn't get claimed too, strip the music out and change the whole feel of the video, or leave it up. I left it up. It kept growing, it kept earning, and I never saw a cent of it. At the time, I assumed it was a fluke, deleted that song from our library, and kept going.
Then, a few years ago, I woke up to another claim on a video that had been out for years, using a song I know I bought from PremiumBeat. I disputed it and lost again, and after that, the claims came in by the hundreds. Videos from more than a decade ago, with music I had legally licensed, were suddenly being claimed. Some of those songs are on practically every royalty-free music site on the internet. Others used to be, until they were pulled, and now someone says they own them, even though I paid for a license eight years ago.
It's Worse for Music Channels
As bad as this has been for me, it's worse for creators who talk about music for a living. Rick Beato, one of the biggest music channels on YouTube, sits down with musicians to break down their own songs and still gets claimed nonstop, even though discussing a song is the kind of use fair use exists to protect. In his video, he says he has had roughly 4,000 claims over nine years.
Musicians who play on camera get hit too, even when they aren't playing the song they're accused of. My favorite example is Davie504. He went into an anechoic chamber, one of the quietest rooms in the world, picked up his bass to play "The Sound of Silence" as a joke, and muted the audio. He played nothing at all, and he says he still got a copyright claim for "The Sound of Silence."
The Same Thing Is Happening in Photography
I own Fstoppers, and over the years we've bought thousands of royalty-free images to use in articles. Every so often, an email arrives saying we owe someone a thousand dollars, or in some cases tens of thousands, for "stealing" an image. I'll look it up, and it's on every stock photo site, available for something like 50 cents. We licensed it legally 12 years ago, and now someone shows up out of nowhere asking for five, 10, 20, or 30 thousand dollars.
I went to court over one of these. I won, and I still lost $27,000 in legal fees. So why would anybody pay to use an image that might get them sued for tens of thousands of dollars a decade later? And why would anyone pay for music again when it could cost you your revenue or put your channel at risk? For the last few years, that's exactly why I stopped using music in my videos at all.
Trying Suno
I kept hearing that AI music had gotten incredibly good, so I tried Suno. I think I paid $10 or $20 for the month, and I started generating songs from text prompts. The crazy thing is that the music sounds incredible. It sounds better than any song I've legally purchased in the last 15 years.
In all the years we used licensed music, nobody ever asked what the songs were, because the songs were never that good. In my last video, the top comment was someone asking what the songs were, saying they tried Shazam and couldn't find them. That's never happened to me before.
The economics aren't close, either. On a site like PremiumBeat, I'd pay around $80 for a song that would show up in thousands of other videos, and it could still get claimed later. With Suno, each song costs a fraction of that, and it's unique to me, so nobody else can put that exact track in their video. I can make it instrumental or give it vocals, write my own lyrics or let the AI write them, and in about a minute I have a song made specifically for my video. Suno's paid plans are the ones that include commercial use, so read the terms before you put a track in a monetized video.
"AI Music Has No Soul"
I've read the comments from people who say they'll never listen to AI music because it's soulless and they want music made by real people. I get it. But my whole life, I've also heard people say they hate computerized music and only want real people playing real instruments. Then look at the charts. So much of what's been popular for the last 20 years is synthesized and built on a computer anyway.
As I get older and listen to the top charts on Spotify, I don't like most of it, and I don't know who most of these artists are. So if I can generate music that sounds like the music I actually like, isn't that better for me than real music I don't like?
Why This One Hits Close to Home
After college, I seriously considered going back to school for music production. I almost went to Full Sail University for its music production program, and at the last minute, I chose photography instead. Now the two things I cared about most, making images and making music, have both been overtaken by AI at the same moment. I have to be honest: AI can generate an image better than anything I've ever taken, instantly and for free, and now the same is true of music.
Because of the copyright trolls, I think nearly every YouTube video will soon use AI-generated music. I also think Spotify will start generating songs tailored to each listener, and people will love them because they were built around their own taste. Plenty of people will fight it, insist they want only human-made music, and keep listening to chart hits that were produced on computers anyway, while the songs made just for them sound better.
On one hand, this is the most exciting technology I've ever seen in my life. On the other hand, it's incredibly sad. Have you started using AI music in your videos, or are you holding out? Let me know in the comments.

3 hours ago
30






English (US) ·