Google's Gemini 4 Carbon edged out Anthropic and OpenAI by a single point in the latest benchmark overhaul, while the gap between proprietary and open-weights models widened sharply.
Alphabet Inc. (GOOGL) price
Full chart and statsLoading chart…
Market cap $4.0T (shares as of 2026-06-30)
P/E (trailing) 16.3 (EPS to 2026-06-30)
Annual operating margin 32.0% (FY ended 2025-12-31)
Forward P/E Unavailable: no dated forecast source
Gloria daily close for session Oct 28, 2026. Market cap and trailing P/E use this close with the SEC share total and trailing diluted earnings, each dated next to its figure. Annual revenue, revenue growth, net income and margin show their own fiscal period and link the 10-K. Current context may postdate this article.
Alphabet Inc. and its peers
Token vs underlying stock
Current comparison for GOOGL. Historical observations may postdate this article.
GOOGLx token unit vs GOOGL share · USD
$325.97Oct 28 UTC
-10.2% over displayed period
● GOOGLx token┄ GOOGL stock: $324.89
Benchmarking AI models has always felt a little like grading students who wrote the exam. The data those models trained on and the tests used to evaluate them often overlap, making scores more a measure of memorization than genuine capability. Artificial Analysis just took a swing at fixing that problem.
The research firm launched Intelligence Index v5 on October 27, 2026, introducing a methodological overhaul that shifts 60% of the composite score to private test sets rather than web-scraped data. The stated goal is to reduce benchmark contamination, a persistent problem where models appear smarter than they are because they have effectively seen the questions before.
How the rankings shook out
At launch, Anthropic’s Claude Opus 5.5 took the top spot with a score of 58. OpenAI placed two models in the index: GPT-6 Astra at 57 and GPT-6.1 Sol at 55. The gap between first and third place across those three was narrow enough to fit in a rounding error.
That changed within 24 hours. On October 28, 2026, Google’s Gemini 4 Carbon posted a score of 59, claiming the leading position by a single point over Claude Opus 5.5.
The index covers nine evaluations across categories including knowledge work, coding, science, and general capability. No single model dominated across all nine, which is the more interesting finding buried beneath the headline rankings.
Each of the nine evaluations carries 25% of the total score, meaning the weighting across categories is equal and the composite reflects a specific set of priorities chosen by Artificial Analysis.
The widening proprietary gap
The more consequential shift in v5 is not who sits at the top. It is what is happening at the bottom of the frontier tier.
In the previous version, v4.3, the performance gap between closed proprietary models and the best open-weights models was 3 points. In v5, that gap has expanded to 12 points.
The best-performing open-weights model in the new index is Moonshot AI’s Kimi K3.1 Pro, which scored 46. Against Gemini 4 Carbon’s 59, that is a 13-point deficit. Against Claude Opus 5.5’s 58, it is a 12-point gap.
For context, open-weights models are those where the model weights are publicly released, allowing developers to run and modify them independently without relying on an API.
Why the methodology change matters
The shift to private evaluations for 60% of the composite score is the design choice that will attract the most scrutiny, for better and worse.
Better, because contamination has been a real and documented problem in AI benchmarking. When training corpora include the internet, and popular benchmarks live on the internet, there is a reasonable chance that a model’s strong performance reflects prior exposure rather than generalizable reasoning. Private test sets that models cannot have trained on are a more honest measure of capability.
Worse, because private evaluations introduce a different trust problem. Researchers and developers reading a leaderboard built on private tests cannot verify the methodology themselves. They are trusting the benchmarking organization to have designed fair, representative tasks and to have administered them consistently across models.
Artificial Analysis also added two new benchmarks in v5, including FrontierCode 2.0, which targets coding capability.
Disclosure: This article was edited by Diego Almada Lopez. For more information on how we create and review content, see our Editorial Policy.

2 weeks ago
35








English (US) ·