A Court Of Thorns & Roses Overlooks A Glaring Problem With Feyre's Night Court Role

Feyre Archeron is a well-loved heroine among A Court of Thorns and Roses readers, and Sarah J. Maas' series proves she's also Prythian’s sweetheart. She is immediately beloved by the Inner Circle and adopted into the Night Court, likely due to her status as Rhysand's mate. The events of the A Court of Thorns and Roses books shed light on how Feyre never felt accepted before; her family showed her no affection or care. Seeing such a deserving protagonist gain a found family and rise to the highest position makes Feyre's character arcs one of the most satisfying of the series.

Surprisingly, Feyre’s sudden transition to becoming High Lady of the Night Court is incredibly smooth. She's soon exploring Velaris, opening a paint studio, and managing all city affairs. However, Maas never offers an explanation of why Feyre’s rule is widely accepted so quickly, despite her being the very first High Lady in history. The role works out for Feyre, as she does prove to be a compassionate, thoughtful, and brave leader. However, Hulu’s upcoming A Court of Thorns and Roses show may have a harder time selling this oversight.

A Court Of Thorns & Roses Doesn't Address An Obvious Problem With Feyre's Night Court Role

It Doesn't Make Sense For Feyre To Take Over So Soon

Custom Image by SR Image Editor

At the time of Feyre’s appointment to High Lady, it makes sense romantically that her relationship with Rhysand leads him to treat her as an equal. At the same time, just because Rhysand trursts Feyre to lead his court after knowing her for just a few months doesn’t mean all the other Fae in Prythian would feel the same. Without knowing the people, culture, or laws, Feyre is immediately thrust into the highest position of power — and she doesn't face any backlash.

If Maas included context suggesting some of the Night Court’s subjects — or even the other High Lords — were hesitant to accept Feyre's new role, then this plot point would feel more realistic. This would have been smart for Maas to include, especially as The Court of Nightmares is already very misogynistic. Feyre rising to power in a more dynamic way would allow for more information about how the people of the Night Court feel about their new High Lady.

Maas choosing to never address this plot point in the books makes it even more glaringly unrealistic. Even when Viviane from the Winter Court probes that she should also be made High Lady, the sentiment falls flat and is largely disregarded. Maas never suggests that the subjects of the Night Court admire Feyre for saving Prythian Under The Mountain, so there is nothing to support the idea of them following her so quickly. This makes it seem like Feyre is only accepted in this role because it's convenient for the plot.

Feyre Becoming High Lady Of The Night Court Can't Be So Easy In Hulu's ACOTAR Show

Hulu’s Upcoming Adaptation Must Make This A Bigger Deal

The last hundred pages of A Court of Mist and Fury serve as a distraction from the glaring inconsistency of Feyre rising to power without a single complaint (except maybe from Keir or Beron). Many high-intensity moments, including the stand-off with Hybern and Feyre returning to the Spring Court, make it possible for Feyre’s title change to fly beneath the radar. However, the ACOTAR television show will have to address this plot point in a more significant way. Yes, Feyre becoming High Lady is awesome. However, without any pushback, it won’t seem realistic or possible.

Related

How Old Feyre Is In The Court Of Thorns & Roses Books (& How Long She Can Live)

Feyre Archeron is fairly young when A Court of Thorns & Roses opens, but how old is she throughout Sarah J. Maas’ best-selling fantasy series?

To give Feyre the credit she deserves for jumping into such a crucial role so suddenly, the ACOTAR show must show Feyre facing adversity to be accepted. Even in fantasy, women in power must be acknowledged for the steps it takes them to get there. Maas choosing to ignore this plot point is not the best way to demonstrate Feyre’s resilience. The upcoming A Court of Thorns and Roses show should include these moments to ensure Feyre’s journey seems more relatable. This also creates future storylines where Feyre overcomes obstacles to prove she deserves to lead.

• 

• 

  Based on the A Court of Thorns and Roses fantasy novel series, A Court of Thorns and Roses is a television adaptation that follows Feyre Archeron, a young woman dragged into the world of faeries after slaying one of their kind. The series will follow her journey through the lands of Prythian and her relationship with one of its lords, Tamlin.